What started as an eviction call over a short-term rental guest reportedly refusing to leave led Sedona police into an alleged organized interstate counterfeiting operation.
A search of a Brewer Road short-term vacation rental in the 900 block on Sept. 3 uncovered what police described as an “organized operation” producing counterfeit cash and fraudulent documents linked to an Aug. 31 traffic stop in Cottonwood, according to a Sedona Police Department report requested by the NEWS.
Cottonwood Police Department officers arrested Carlos Cazelly, 74, and Morgan Gargiulo, 37, following an Aug. 31 traffic stop near the intersection of State Route 260 and East Fir Street.
According to Sedona police reports, investigators later tied both men to multiple false identities, locating forged California driver’s licenses for Cazelly under the names “Claudio Cavalli” and “Jose Reyes,” while Gargiulo used the alias “Angelo Silverio Brioni.”
Following the pair’s identification as persons of interest in Verde Valley forgery investigations, the broader alleged operation was uncovered on Sept. 3, when SPD Officer Stephen Miolla was dispatched at 12:33 p.m. to the Brewer Road rental for an overstayed reservation that had expired at 10 a.m. the previous morning. The renter initially presented an Italian passport identifying herself as “Serafina Abramovich,” but was later confirmed to be Valeria Bednarchik, 32, after allegedly providing officers with three variations of her name.
Bednarchik claimed that she had nowhere to go and no money because “her husband was in a vehicle accident and was in a hospital in Prescott, but she was unsure which hospital. She continued to state that she did not have a vehicle or money … because her husband, ‘Angelo Silverio Brioni,’ usually takes care of the money,” Miolla wrote in the report.
Bednarchik was told to find a way to pay for the rental or to vacate the property by 4 p.m.
SPD was called at 4:50 p.m. and told Bednarchik had not left; the property manager saw her in the hot tub with her 6-year-old son, with no indication they were leaving.
“I arrived on scene and spoke with [Bednarchik] and advised her she needed to pack up her belongings, as she was no longer welcome in the residence,” Miolla wrote. “Permission was given by [the rental manager] for officers to enter the residence.”
Officers Andrew Marshall and Troy Zellner remained in the rental while Miolla spoke outside with the manager until Zellner showed Miolla a counterfeit $100 bill found inside, where there was also allegedly an uncut sheet of three counterfeit $100 bills.
“I observed the sheet and the bills that appeared to be counterfeit,” Miolla wrote. “I spoke with [Bednarchik], who stated that her son wanted money to play with, so her husband, Brioni, printed some for the child. [Bednarchik] stated it was just a toy and a game for her son.”
“I asked if she ever used the counterfeit money while in the United States, to which she stated ‘no,'” Miolla wrote. “I advised her we had recently arrested individuals using the money that looked similar to the ones in her possession.”
Miolla questioned Bednarchik about her husband’s whereabouts, noting that she had not confirmed his presence at any facility and warning her that he was likely in custody.
“She finally confessed that her husband left her and her child approximately two days ago and she has not heard from him,” Miolla wrote. “She admitted to making up that Brioni was [in] the hospital and that he left after they got into a verbal dispute.”
Bednarchik was read her Miranda rights at 5:25 p.m. and arrested at 5:30 p.m. for possession of counterfeit marks, possession of a forgery device “after locating a printer used to print the counterfeit money with linen paper sheets near the printer, as well as a lamination machine used to laminate multiple driver’s licenses from various states,” forgery, providing false name and possession of a dangerous drug, after methamphetamine was allegedly found.
The seized counterfeit $100 bills are consistent with two other incidents in Sedona, according to the report.
“The quantity and variety of items located were significant and appeared consistent with an organized operation involving counterfeit currency, fraudulent identification documents and other forms of document fabrication,” SPD K-9 Officer Catherine Beers wrote.
Officers searching the residence found a printer, a laminating machine and packages of ivory and white linen paper with a texture similar to the counterfeit bills. They counted at least five counterfeit $100 bills and one counterfeit $20 bill and the report notes that more suspected counterfeit currency kept turning up after that count. Among the items SPD also found were a paper cutter, inks, enamel sprays and drying fans, along with materials apparently used to try to replicate the blue security strip on U.S. currency.
Other items included driver’s licenses and ID cards from several states, passports and related documents, two forged Texas license plates and vehicle title documents, according to the report.
“I found a burnt piece of the counterfeit money that had been left in the fireplace,” Marshall wrote. “It had the same color and consistency as the other bills found. There were other burnt items that looked to have the consistency of paper in the fireplace, but were unrecoverable.”
SPD made contact with the biological father of Bednarchik’s son in California, who stated that Brioni’s real name is Morgan Gargiulo, who was booked into the Yavapai County Jail on Aug. 31. Additionally, SPD confirmed Bednarchik’s identity after date-of-birth information provided “was associated with a missing-person-related entry involving her child,” Beers wrote. Bednarchik had allegedly violated a custody agreement and taken her son outside of California against a court order.
The Superior Court of California served Bednarchik a court order at about 7 p.m. requiring that her son be placed in the custody of his biological father. The Arizona Department of Child Safety took custody of the child at 9:20 p.m. Additionally, Todo, Bednarchik’s small brown dog, was taken to the Humane Society of Sedona at 6:06 p.m.
Gargiulo faces 13 counts in Yavapai County that include seven counts of possessing a forged instrument, alongside single counts of fraudulent schemes and artifices, theft of a means of transportation, altering a vehicle identification number and identity theft. He is also charged with felony second-degree escape and resisting arrest after allegedly attempting to flee on foot at the detention facility.
Cazelly faces 14 felony charges in Yavapai County accusing him of operating a fraud scheme, possessing and trying to spend fake cash and forged IDs and driving a stolen vehicle, including nine counts of forgery for carrying or passing counterfeit documents, two counts of running an organized fraud scheme and single counts of identity theft, theft by misrepresentation and car theft.
Bednarchik faces six charges: illegal drug possession, multiple counts of possessing forgery equipment and adapted counterfeiting devices, a counterfeit trademark violation and obstructing justice by refusing to provide a truthful name.
“The case is being handed over to the Secret Service,” SPD wrote in its initial announcement. The U.S. Secret Service was founded in July 1865 specifically to investigate counterfeiting.



















