Three people face federal charges after being arrested locally with counterfeit money.
Cottonwood Police Department officers arrested Carlos Cazelly and Morgan Gargiulo following a traffic stop near the intersection of State Route 260 and East Fir Street in Cottonwood on Aug. 31.
Valeria Bednarchik, of California, was arrested by Sedona police on Sept. 3 in Sedona in connection with the Cottonwood case.
Both Gargiulo and Cazelly were initially identified as persons of interest during an ongoing investigation into a series of forgery incidents reported at businesses throughout the Verde Valley, where the pair allegedly attempted to use forged currency.
CPD Sgt. Ryan Gibson said that the previous day, CPD received a call that the bills were allegedly used to make purchases at a local business. Gibson did not have an estimate of how much counterfeit currency the pair allegedly used.
“I don’t have those details as of now,” Gibson said about how much counterfeit currency was seized in the arrest.
During the traffic stop and subsequent investigation, Cottonwood officers allege that both subjects provided fraudulent foreign identification documents in what police state was an attempt to conceal their true identities.
Officers also reportedly located a large quantity of suspected counterfeit currency in the subjects’ possession, which was consistent with counterfeit bills previously reported in the ongoing forgery investigation.
Following the arrests, officers continued investigating into the vehicle and state it had been reported stolen from California. The original Vehicle Identification Numbers had been covered or altered with fraudulent information and the vehicle reportedly displayed a fraudulent license plate.
Once Gargiulo’s true identity was uncovered, a records check revealed multiple felony warrants out of California for vehicle theft-related charges.
The investigation has involved close coordination with surrounding law enforcement agencies as officers and detectives work to determine the full scope of the suspects’ alleged activities and identify additional businesses or individuals who may have been victimized.
Cazelly and Gargiulo were booked into the Yavapai County Jail in Prescott on charges of forgery, taking the identity of another, theft, possession of a stolen vehicle, conspiracy, escape and aggravated assault on law enforcement.
“Just prior to booking, when arriving at a booking facility, one of the suspects [Gargiulo] attempted to flee custody and escape on foot, which led to a foot pursuit and a brief physical struggle during that time as one of the officers received some minor injuries to his leg,” Gibson said.
Three days later, Sedona police made a third arrest connected to the case at a short-term rental in the 900-block of Brewer Road, the city of Sedona posted to social media on Sept. 4.
SPD officers had been called out to the scene at 12:33 p.m.
“Officers responded to a civil issue,” Sedona police stated. “Upon arrival it was discovered that Bednarchik was [allegedly] in possession of counterfeit money, a printer used to make counterfeit money, as well as other forgery tools. She was placed under arrest and the case is being handed over to the Secret Service.”
Bednarchik was also arrested with “a substance that appears to be methamphetamine,” city spokeswoman Julie Graham wrote.
Additional charges may be added as the investigation continues.
The U.S. Secret Service has been under the jurisdiction of the U.S. Department of Homeland Security since 2003, but was created under the U.S. Department of the Treasury in 1865 to combat counterfeiting.



















