54.8 F
Sedona
Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Goldsmith: Teaching students and teachers for 42 years8 min read

Karyl Goldsmith poses for a photo with some of her former students. David Jolkovski/Larson Newsapapers


After 42 years teaching, including three decades at Sedona Red Rock High School, former English teacher Karyl Goldsmith will be retiring at the end of the 2024-25 school year. Goldsmith will be ending her career as Sedona-Oak Creek School District’s director of curriculum and instruction, but she first joined SOCSD as a teacher in December 1994, following the high school’s first semester of operation.

“I think it’s because I thought I could make a difference, and I hope that’s why people go into any profession, because you think you have what it takes to change somebody’s life, to give them the tools that they might need,” Goldsmith said, reflecting on her career as an educator.

“It’s funny how I probably walk by this every day but don’t appreciate all the names and what so many of these students have gone on to accomplish,” Goldsmith said, pointing to a plaque of the inaugural class of students in 1994 that also lists her name. Those names include that of Leonard Barrow, who was the SRRHS athletic director.

“Karyl and I usually were the first ones to get there every morning at the school,” Barrow said. “They hired her to fill a slot I had at first, because I was doing some liaison work with Mingus [Union High School] and Camp Verde [School] on things like computer training … and Karyl took a couple of my classes. The only way to describe Karyl is that she’s a fantastic teacher and a fantastic person. She was just remarkable to work with, we were so fortunate to have her.”

SOCSD Superintendent Tom Swaninger, Ph.D., said that one of the first things he noticed when he joined the district a year and a half ago was that Goldsmith had been one of the most respected educators in the district since its founding.

“She has made legendary contributions to not only her students but to our families and teachers,” Swaninger said. “In her most recent role as the director of curriculum and instruction, we have seen many of our teachers grow substantially from her expertise. She is in a non-evaluative role, which allows an environment for educators to take risks with their teaching practices and try things that are a bit outside of their comfort zone, and then to be able to receive coaching and guidance from her. She’s been wonderful, and while her retirement is something that we are celebrating for her personally, she will be a difficult person to replace.”

Advertisement

West Sedona School Principal Alisa Stieg echoed that sentiment in a tribute to Goldsmith when Goldsmith was named one of the staff members of the month during the SOCSD Governing Board meeting on March 4.

“My first year at West Sedona School has been extremely challenging and rewarding, and I have met some of the most amazing people,” Stieg said. “And of all the people that I’ve met, you are one of the most outstanding. You are admired by so very many people that are so lucky to be able to work with and learn from you. I am one of those people that has been able to work with and learn from you, and I am so grateful that you have been a part of the growth and the change to our school.

“Our students love having you, our staff love having you, and we are so fortunate that you stepped up in the position that you did, that you broadened your reach as far and wide as you did.”

Prior to the founding of SOCSD, Sedona students in Coconino County went to Flagstaff high schools, while those on the Yavapai County side and the Village of Oak Creek went to Mingus Union High School in Cottonwood. When Sedona residents founded SOCSD, Goldsmith was already among its most experienced teachers, having spent seven years in the classroom.

Goldsmith herself graduated from Havre High School in northern Montana in 1976.

“I went to the University of Montana and graduated in 1980,” Goldsmith said. She majored in English and French. “I pretty much always wanted to be a teacher. Even as a little kid, like, I’d pack a pretend briefcase and bring my stuffies into a little circle and unpack my briefcase and teach my stuffed animals … I can’t even remember what the lesson plan was for the stuffed animals. I think we did the alphabet, but we did go over nursery rhymes.”

Being able to instill that ability with her colleagues in her final year Goldsmith cited as what she was most proud of over her tenure.

“I was among the most experienced teachers because we had pretty much all new hires when they opened the school,” Goldsmith said. “I became the one that you didn’t get away with anything in my classroom. And then I helped mentor some of the other teachers on best practices. And we moved Barrow — who’s still in Sedona and a Marine. He moved into the dean of students position, and that helped get the kinks out as well — that we had some solid kind of leadership and parameters for kids.”

In her own life, the parameters of a thermostat in the house she rented in Missoula, Mont., in 1979 altered the course of her life — and that of her future husband, Daniel Goldsmith, M.D., who she married in 1983.

“We were living in the upper floor and we had control of [Daniel’s] heat,” Goldsmith said, recalling how the couple met. “He had the basement apartment, and I didn’t realize our heat controlled his heat, and he came up one night and said, ‘Can you please turn up the heat a little bit?’ Then I made him dinner because he was freezing, and we had some… sweet and sour pork.”

After the couple married, they had two children: Benjamin was born in 1986 and Hannah in 1988.

The couple decided to escape the cold after Daniel’s medical career took them to New Hampshire, Minnesota and Michigan, and relocated to Sedona, where Daniel Goldsmith became a family practice physician until he retired eight years ago.

“High expectations have always been something I’ve valued and strived to uphold every day,” Goldsmith said. “I was recently talking to someone whose daughter I taught. She’s 19 now, and she mentioned that I never gave up on her, never lowered my expectations and believed she could succeed at a level she didn’t think was possible … Whether a student is in special education, ELL [English Language Learner], autistic or faces any other challenge, I won’t lower my expectations. I’ll raise them to meet those expectations because that’s what they deserve.”

Goldsmith said that her post-retirement plan is “to get bored,” which she admitted might not come easily. Travel remains a priority for Goldsmith and her husband. After spending a month each in Italy, France and Iceland, they had planned an extended trip through Scotland, England and Ireland that was derailed by the COVID-19 pandemic response, and they now intend to complete that outing this fall. Goldsmith said that they plan to spend a full month in each destination to understand the local culture.

Goldsmith also said that she looked forward to spending time at their second home in Shingle Springs, Calif., and with her grandson, Arlo, babysitting, taking him to the park, visiting the beach and teaching him to swim. She also plans to take regular trips to Seattle to visit her other grandson, Winston, and the rest of the family.

Goldsmith wasn’t always the easiest teacher, but her rigor pushed many students to achieve more.

“I don’t think I’ve ever learned and retained so much information from a teacher as I have from Goldsmith,” said graduating senior Yonas Rahman, who is enrolling at Barrett, The Honors College at Arizona State University. “With all the college preparation I did this year between scholarship applications and essays, I used everything she taught me. I think that’s why I got into four out of the five schools I applied to. She’s strict with her students, but it’s to make them better, and it really works.”

Former student and current freshman at Northern Arizona University Maxwell Jankowski agreed.

“To find a teacher as qualified as Goldsmith is going to take a very long time,” Jankowski said. “She gave me a great introduction to college. I would be much less prepared for college if it weren’t for her teaching, because she went above and beyond, and I haven’t struggled with writing at all. That’s in large part due to how she taught, especially with academic papers. … She had a unique ability to connect with people.”

Graduating senior Emily Frey, who will be studying biology at the University of Pennsylvania, said Goldsmith’s class changed the way she felt about writing.

“She’s so prepared and always has the most fun and engaging lessons. I used to feel pretty uncomfortable with writing and wasn’t very confident in my skills,” Frey said. “But after taking her class, practicing a lot, and learning from her guidance and experience, I improved so much. Her lessons were always enjoyable, so it never felt like a drag going to class. Everything was tied into a book we were reading, and sometimes she’d even bring in food. One time, we did a crime scene activity where we had to walk around the classroom and try to decipher clues.”

“You never know for sure if you made a difference,” Goldsmith said. “I’ve been here long enough to have kids come back and apologize to me for … being kind of little stinkers, which is always amazing, and I came to the realization that everybody eventually grows up.”

Joseph K Giddens

Joseph K. Giddens grew up in southern Arizona and studied natural resources at the University of Arizona. He later joined the National Park Service in many different roles focusing on geoscience education throughout the West. Drawn to deep time and ancient landscapes he’s worked at: Dinosaur National Monument, Petrified Forest National Park, Badlands National Park and Saguaro National Park among several other public land sites. Prior to joining Sedona Red Rock News, he worked for several Tucson outlets as well as the Williams-Grand Canyon News and the Navajo-Hopi Observer. He frequently is reading historic issues of the Tombstone Epitaph newspaper and daydreaming about rockhounding. Contact him at jgiddens@larsonnewspapers.com or (928) 282-7795 ext. 122.

- Advertisement -