While Mayor Rob Adams and Councilwoman Barbara Litrell testified in support of the National Scenic Area designation at the June 10 U.S. House Resources Subcommittee on National Parks, Forests and Public Land, there was opposition present as well.
Holly Mabery, representing the Sedona-Verde Valley Association of Realtors, presented verbal and written testimony on the long-standing concerns of her board, the city of Cottonwood, Cornville Community Association, Sedona 30 and Citizens for an Alternate Route.
Mabery said it was extremely important for the subcommittee to hear there are groups and individuals opposing the NSA designation.
She also said it seemed like Adams was speaking for the entire Verde Valley in his testimony, so it was crucial for the subcommittee to hear the other side.
“We feel this bill is a direct threat to private property rights and the ability for future generations of this area to self-govern,” she said. “The legal precedent set in other NSAs and the designation itself continues to be used by special-interest groups as a means to sue and block management, infrastructure and needs for areas with this special designation.”
Mabery was representing 650 real estate agents and brokers and another 105 associate members throughout the Verde Valley.
She said the group felt it was important to have a voice, especially to counteract the testimony of Adams, and added it was important for the subcommittee to realize there are many people not in favor of this designation.
Adams told the subcommittee at the hearing there were 5,000 letters that were gathered in support of the NSA legislation, but she testified the majority of those were gathered and signed by tourists with no education or facts presented.
Mabery added the proponents of the bill gathered the letters under the pretense and question of “Don’t you think we should save this scenic beauty?”
She said replacing Amendment 12 of the Coconino National Forest Management Plan for this area and giving Congress more control in the Verde Valley seems ridiculous, and added Amendment 12, a provision that in effect ended land exchanges in the Sedona area, was adopted in 1998.
“Why would we want Congress to have control over anything in the Verde Valley right now?” she asked.
Mabery said she thought the June 10 hearing went pretty well and feels the subcommittee heard loud and clear not everyone wants this designation.
“I would submit the community has come together and spoken with regard to their wants and needs,” she testified. “That was in the form of Amendment 12. This designation is not needed.”
She added the NSA designation is far from a slam dunk.
















