After listening to mixed opinions from 21 people Wednesday, May 12, the Sedona City Council recommended the new council and city staff create a resolution opposing Senate Bill 1070.
The motion stated that the Sedona City Council opposes SB 1070, the immigration bill recently signed by Gov. Jan Brewer.
The council also directed city staff to work with elected state representatives to look into a more humane way to deal with immigration reform.
The bill requires police officers to determine the immigration status of people if there is reasonable suspicion they are illegal immigrants and to arrest people who are unable to provide documentation proving they are in the country legally. The bill also makes it a crime to transport someone who is an illegal immigrant or to hire day laborers off the street.
The vote passed 3-0, with Councilwoman Pud Colquitt abstaining out of respect for Councilman Dan Surber who asked for the special meeting.
Mayor Rob Adams, Vice Mayor Cliff Hamilton and Councilman Mark DiNunzio did not attend the meeting.
Resident Linda Rachel said when she first saw the bill, she wondered what the real intention was as well as the outcome.
She said the law as it reads would do nothing to improve border security nor prevent human and drug trafficking.
Rachel said 25 percent of her family came to America and became citizens, and the other 75 percent did not apply for citizenship after coming to the United States.
Resident Bobbie Surber said the bill does nothing but hurt Arizona.
She said if the bill becomes law, it will affect businesses and tourism. She added it will put more pressure on Sedona police officers who will be required to ask for proof of citizenship from people.
Surber said she is proud of her Mexican-American heritage, noting her husband, Dan Surber, is of Latino descent.
She asked for a show of hands for people opposing the bill from the packed audience in the council chambers, and about 50 percent of the individuals attending raised their hands.
Resident Don Troutman said he does not think the bill is the answer to need for illegal immigration reform.
He said the federal government should sit down and work with those wanting to come to America, and added the process should be expedited.
“We cannot punish people for bettering themselves,” he said, and added the hotel industry, where many work, will be greatly impacted by this legislation.
Resident Doreen Slevin asked council to not take a stand since the state law is only a carbon copy of similar federal legislation.
She said it is understandable why so many Mexicans want to live the American dream, but added they need to do it legally, not illegally.
“This is a way to wake everyone up,” she said, “We don’t want to be stepped on.”
Resident Ted Jones said his concern is Dan Surber is linked to the school district in some way. Surber’s wife, Bobbie Surber, is the Sedona-Oak Creek School District School Board president.
Jones said he would not want his children to attend a school district that thinks opposition to the bill is the way to go.
He said there are rules and laws in America, and people who want to live here need to follow them.
Resident David Hartlerode said he is enraged and disgusted with the bill, and added everyone’s heritage can be traced to another country,
Resident Florencia Gaspar Marquez said the Latino community does not want this law to be taken to its full power.
“We just want to work. I am here to ask that you speak on our behalf,” she said.
Resident R.W. Worrell wondered why Sedona was taking a stand on an Arizona bill, saying this is not the “Republic of Sedona.”
He said every American should be in favor of this bill, and said the bill makes it clear individuals have to abide by the law.
Councilwoman Nancy Scagnelli said she appreciated everyone attended the meeting, which she added was her last one as a councilwoman.
She said she has a lot of friends in the Latino community and is aware of the divisions.
“This is an unprecedented law,” she said, adding it is bringing bad press to the state.
“This bill does nothing for border security. We need to figure put a way to deal with cultural diversity,” Scagnelli said
[Dan] Surber said his goal in asking for the meeting was to open the issue up for dialogue.
Councilman Jerry Frey said he has no problems with the bill, but said he was going to vote in favor of opposing it to support Surber out of respect.
















