Outgoing members voted for raise to entice future younger candidates
Sedona Mayor Brian Fultz will be making $1,700 a month, up from $800, and Sedona City Council members will receive $1,350 monthly, up from $550, with all members now eligible to participate in the city’s health, dental and vision plans at the rate of other city employees following a 4-3 decision by the outgoing City Council — with interim Mayor Holli Ploog, and Councilwomen Kathy Kinsella and Charlotte Hosseini opposed — on Tuesday, Nov. 10, just before the swearing-in of its new members.
The pay increase and healthcare was predicated on a desire by council members to have younger people with different opinions running in the 2028 election.
“That was the driving motivation: To get some younger people on the council that have a different view of what the future of Sedona is and wants to be, and how to get there,” said Councilman and Chairman of the City Council Compensation Work Group Pete Furman. Furman, who did not run for reelection, retired from the council following the meeting before the swearing in of the new council. Additionally, a refrain from council and the work group was that the council has an “overrepresentation of retirees.” according to the work group’s recommendations.
The new compensation rates go into effect on Friday, Jan. 1, and eligibility for the new healthcare benefits begins at the start of the next budget year on Thursday July 1. The changes stem from the work group’s findings, with the vote marking Furman’s final action on the council. The discussion was scheduled in a special session ahead of the regular meeting because any changes to council compensation must align with election cycles.
“In retrospect, it was obvious the answers we were going to get: Everyone that has served this council before from the city has the same mindset,” Furman said. “It was a civic responsibility. They just did it. It wasn’t really the issue, [and the] vast majority of them are all retired. So they just they had the older school mentality of what public service is meant to be, and without the current grounding of what living in Sedona is like today, and everyone that I talked to anyhow was willing to pay some, but not a big amount.”
The new salary going into effect at the start of the year was the major reason for Ploog and Kinsella’s opposition. Ploog and Kinsella desired to have the pay increase go into effect for the next council, and Hosseini agreed, while also objecting to the unfairness of giving council members health insurance when regular part-time city workers don’t get it
“I really have a problem treating counselors as some sort of special creatures who can work, who are deemed to be working more hours and eligible for health insurance when a city employee who is working 20 hours or 25, whatever the cutoff is, is not eligible,” Hosseini said.
Furman said that council can treat the increase as a starting point of further increasing compensation or benefits — such as child or elder care or transportation — with the idea of doing so floated as an action during council’s annual retreat next month, when they set their priorities for 2027. Additionally, the work group requested that compensation be indexed to state’s minimum wage to avoid the need to go before council for future adjustments.
“I’d like to see some additional benefits we could add, whether that is just a monthly sum that people could use it for transportation, they could use for childcare, they could use it for whatever the issues are, and like they’ve done in in other cities to do this, not just limit it to to healthcare,” Ploog said.
Prioritizing healthcare over retirement benefits was chosen to incentivize younger people to run for office without enticing “career politicians,” Furman said.
“We don’t want this to be viewed as a career opportunity,” Fultz said.
“I can say, speaking from my own personal experience, this has pushed out a lot of my actual job, a lot,” said Councilman Derek Pfaff, who works as a lawyer. “You can debate whether this should be a volunteer position or although most legislators do in fact get paid, but it shouldn’t cost somebody money to serve in this position, and although this is a step in the right direction, this doesn’t even scratch the surface of what it’s cost me. I support the proposal.”
“Councilor Pfaff and I are the only two that are not retirees, and I don’t sit around and think about what my opportunity cost has been over the last four years, but I know it’s been very, very significant, and I’m not up here complaining about that,” Fultz said. “It’s a reality, and I’m fortunate that I can absorb that.
“But again, if we’re serious about getting people up here, then we need to take some of that uncertainty away.”
Newly sworn-in Councilman Tony Hauserman said to the NEWS that he would have voted for the increased compensation because “right now it precludes young people in their productive years from running, and it winds up that only retirees essentially can afford to be on Council … and I think that hurts us not having some younger people’s viewpoints as to what are the best policies.”
“For me, it would probably be a ‘no,’” newly sworn-in Councilman Jean-Christophe Buillet said to the NEWS about what his vote would have been. “I understand that there’s not much remuneration. However, I think of the role as more of a volunteer role. I would say for the mayor, I would be in favor of raising the pay, but for the council, it feels kind of like an honorific role that has — although there’s a lot of time demand — it’s not quite the same as the mayor.”
As a future agenda item following the vote, Kinsella asked for a discussion with the city’s lobbyist Kathy Senseman about how the new Democratic majorities in both chambers of the Arizona State Legislature could affect the city’s political interests. That discussion will take place during council’s next regular meeting on Tuesday, Nov. 24, along with a vote on Senseman’s $100,000 contract. Additionally, council is scheduled to vote on the city’s new Consolidated Fee Schedule.


















