The red rocks are starting to pop with color and the market is doing something interesting. As we head into the fall season, the data from September and October is telling a more nuanced story than the headline numbers might suggest — and if you’re thinking about buying or selling in Sedona, there are a few things worth paying attention to.
City of Sedona (86336): inventory drops, prices recovering
After a slow summer, average sales prices in 86336 bounced back in September to $1.30 million — up from the $1.16 million we saw in July and August when the summer lull hit. The first chart above shows how prices peaked around $1.58 million back in May and June, dipped through the summer heat, and have been working their way back up. That’s a pretty normal Sedona seasonal pattern.
More importantly, look at what happened with inventory. September’s months of supply came in at 5.30 — down sharply from 6.79 the prior period. That’s actually a meaningful shift. A few weeks ago we were sitting in technical buyer’s market territory; now we’re back on the seller side of balanced. Properties sold were down 13% year-over-year, but the sale-to-list ratio held firm at 96.7%, which tells me the buyers who are in the market are serious and paying close to ask.
The year-to-date numbers reinforce the longer arc: average sales price for 86336 is running at $1.32 million and the price per square foot is tracking at $539 for the month. That’s a healthy market, even with volume down from last year’s pace.
Village of Oak Creek (86351): suddenly more inventory than Sedona
This one caught my eye. For most of 2026, the Village had been the tighter market — fewer months of supply, more action at the lower price points. That flipped in October. The most recent snapshot shows 7.13 months of supply in 86351, crossing above that six-month balanced market threshold into buyer’s territory. At the same time, average sales prices dropped to $869K, down 34% from the prior period. Now, part of that is the mix of what closed — a few higher-end sales can swing a 15-transaction month significantly — but the inventory number is real.
What’s interesting is the sale-to-list ratio in the Village actually improved to 99.0% this period. So even with more inventory, buyers are paying nearly full ask when they engage. That tells me the softness isn’t panic — it’s a market finding its footing after a very busy summer where sales were up 83% year-over-year.
For buyers targeting the Village, this could be a window. More choices, motivated sellers, but the comp data still suggests full-price offers are the norm when a home is priced right.
The bigger picture
Statewide, Arizona’s September housing report showed 41,949 listings, sales down 9.4% year-over-year, and a median sales price of $430,995. Sedona, as always, is operating in a completely different stratosphere — which is exactly why locals don’t pay much attention to statewide headlines.
Year-to-date through October, Coldwell Banker Realty continues to lead the Sedona/Verde Valley market by a comfortable margin — 442.5 sides and over $266 million in volume, well ahead of the field. For those keeping score at home, that’s more than 14% of the market, both by transaction count and dollar volume.
The next 60 days are typically when the motivated buyers come out — people who want to be settled before the holidays or the new year. If you’re a seller and you’ve been waiting, now’s not the time to go quiet on pricing. And if you’re a buyer, the inventory data in the Village in particular is worth a second look.
As always, I’m happy to talk through what this means for your specific situation. Reach out anytime.



















