45.4 F
Sedona
Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Guest Perspective: Vote ‘NO’ on ‘home rule’4 min read

Pro & Con Arguments on Proposition 400

The following is an opinion piece against Proposition 400, Sedona’s Alternative Expenditure Limitation, commonly known as “home rule.” Arizona voters approved a tax reform package in 1980, subsequently added to the Arizona State Constitution. This reform limited what cities and towns could spend in their annual budget and gave the state the authority to impose a limit to spending. This Alternative Expenditure Limitation requires a vote every four years to allow a town, city or county to set the expenditure limit annually, based on the budget adopted by the town or city council or county board of supervisors. For the counter argument, “Vote ‘YES’ on ‘home rule'” by Sedona City Councilman Deref Pfaff, CLICK HERE. These opinion pieces were not fact-checked and only edited for punctuation and Associated Press and Larson Newspapers style.

Vote ‘NO’ on ‘home rule’

Well here we are again, the four-year cycle. We hear the begging, pleading and scare tactics from the city of Sedona, its employees and organizations receiving city assistance supporting their programs.

We hear comments, many emotional, from some residents that are influenced by bad or misleading information. The city wants no oversight on spending. Welcome to our political cycle.

If “home rule” does not pass, we’re told that council cannot spend the money it has collected. It is controlled by the state. We lose those funds into some black hole … all are false.

The city collected the money and council should be able to do what they want and a “no” vote limits their spending actions. Well, yes it does. It also makes them more responsible to the public and less to their personal ideologies.

Read the city’s web site on “home rule,” you will think the world is coming to an end. It was again brought to the city’s attention at a meeting last Friday that the city is in violation of two Arizona Statutes prohibiting all cities form presenting an unbalanced argument on these issues.

Advertisement

One councilor at the meeting said the city attorney — who has given notice and is moving out of state — said it was not an issue. But at the same meeting, a city employee, explaining “home rule” did a very balanced presentation. Games? You be the judge.
The council: Good people, good intentions, but what qualifications? I don’t disparage anyone on the council, all have been successful in their careers.

Their experience? Overseeing 202 city employees, 45 earning more than $100K with automatic 5% and 10% pay increases for a city of 9,700 people, a 6% decline in population from 2000, but a budget of $103.3 million, should create questions.

Average Sedona household income is $74,000, per person is $59,000. That’s a budget of $10,600 per resident and $511,000 per employee. If we look at a comparable western city average, Snowflake, Winslow, Chino Valley, Arizona; Delta and Fruita, Colorado; and Socorro, New Mexico; populations ranging from 6,736 to 14,307 — all with some tourist activity — average number employees is 138. Average budget per resident is $3,555. Average budget for all these cities is $35,435,551. Why is Sedona’s budget $68 million higher?

Forest Road Extension had a $14.7 million cost overrun. The Uptown garage initial estimated cost, $11 million, final cost with change orders, $26.4 million.

The “free” shuttle system for tourists, annual cost $1.4. Uptown, $1 million to change two lanes out of town to two lanes into town from the canyon, jamming up the “Y” roundabout all the way back to Tlaquepaque. Then $4.5 million for a “no help” zipper lane.

We elected new councilors and before they were seated, the existing council acquired the Cultural Park for $23 million, cash and bond. One council person stated, “we had to buy it so we could figure out what to do with it.” And then the council sued the initiative to keep it as a Cultural Park supported by roughly 1,500 citizens.

In 2018, “home rule” passed in the primary. We were the first in Arizona to place a citizen initiative on the November ballot to establish a Permanent Base Adjustment, PBA. That adjustment was set at $35 million — $39 million was the previous actual year expenditures. Today, based on inflation, PBA would be at $41 million. Council told the people to vote “no.”

If you vote “no,” small grants at $350K, arts and culture, $200K are not affected and the city can run the “shall” have services directed by the state. The limit is $31,692,437 including exemptions. If we need to spend more, the council can request a one time override each may which must be approved by sedona voters.

And in 2028, council can put PBA on the ballot with a starting number of $58 million and cut our city sales and bed tax by 1% each helping local businesses and reducing our costs.

Forty-seven Arizona cities operate under PBA, 38 use temporary “home rule.” Make city government accountable with more citizen involvement, vote no on “home rule.” It is not the end of the world; it is a start to a new era of responsible government.

Mike Schroeder

Sedona

Mike Schroeder

- Advertisement -