Multifamily rezoning rejected

The Sedona City Council unanimously rejected a rezoning request on Dec. 9 for 9.5-acre parcels at 50 Tranquil Avenue and 80 Rigby Road that would have allowed high-density development of up to 20 units per acre, citing its lack of attached developer or concrete plans. David Jolkovski/Larson Newspapers

The Sedona City Council unani­mously rejected a request Dec. 9 to rezone 50 Tranquil Ave. and 80 Rigby Road that would have allowed high-density housing development in the future; however, there was no develop­ment plan or developer attached to the proposal.

The property owners, Kim Soo Young and James Spindelman, were seeking to rezone 9.5 acres from Single Family and Manufactured Home zone that allows four dwelling units per acre to High-Density Multifamily that would allow 20 dwelling units per acre.

“While the application would increase the amount of land available for high-density multifamily housing, the only commitment to housing avail­ability is a prohibition on short-term rentals for 30 years from the date of zoning approval,” according to the staff report. “With no development plan or other commitments related to diversity or affordability, it is difficult to deter­mine how a project on this property could address housing needs.”

The owners were offering 30% of the units for workforce housing, a 30-year prohibition on short-term rentals and the construction and full funding of a shared-use path connecting Tranquil Avenue to Madole Road.

“We have more discretion than the staff has,” Mayor Holli Ploog said.

“The staff must follow literally what the code says. We do not have to do that, and so I just can’t see us at this point giving up our only ability and for the public’s only ability to come and be able to voice their concerns with the zoning change.”

Additionally, the Sedona Community Plan outlines the area for development as multi-family residential and mixed use.

Council was unwilling to give up the zone change without seeing a developer attached to the project.

The Planning and Zoning Commission previously voted 6-1 to recommend denial of the zone change, consistent with staff’s recommendation, and unanimously voted to deny the Conditional Use Permit.

“I don’t believe that RM-3 is compatible with the neighborhood. I don’t believe that the circulation and traffic issues for those two private roads and Tranquil … is respectful of the neighborhood,” said Councilwoman Charlotte Hosseini, who attended remotely. “I don’t believe the 30% affordability percentage is sufficient for the density that is being proposed. I would support medium density, but that is not the request of the owner. And I actually encourage any interested developer to do it themselves and make their own proposals [and] purchase the property. They’ve heard what we’re looking for, and I think they may get a different reception with a different kind of project.”

With the denial the property will retains its current zoning unless a new application is submitted.

Out of the 25 speakers in the public comment period, approxi­mately 10 spoke in favor for the zone change.

Joseph K Giddens

Joseph K. Giddens grew up in southern Arizona and studied natural resources at the University of Arizona. He later joined the National Park Service in many different roles focusing on geoscience education throughout the West. Drawn to deep time and ancient landscapes he’s worked at: Dinosaur National Monument, Petrified Forest National Park, Badlands National Park and Saguaro National Park among several other public land sites. Prior to joining Sedona Red Rock News, he worked for several Tucson outlets as well as the Williams-Grand Canyon News and the Navajo-Hopi Observer. He frequently is reading historic issues of the Tombstone Epitaph newspaper and daydreaming about rockhounding. Contact him at jgiddens@larsonnewspapers.com or (928) 282-7795 ext. 122.

Exit mobile version