45.8 F
Sedona
Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Sedona City Council hears plans for Western Gateway7 min read

Jay Hicks, principal landscape architect at Dig Studio, answers councilors’ questions during the presentation of the draft Western Gateway Master Plan at the Sedona City Council meeting on Wednesday, Sept. 10. Photos by David Jolkovski/Larson Newspapers

The Sedona City Council held its first public meeting on the Western Gateway Master Plan, drawing about 60 residents for a marathon session on Sept. 10. The discussion centered on the possible redevelopment of the 41-acre former Sedona Cultural Park, home to the now inactive 5,550-seat venue Georgia Frontiere Performing Arts Pavilion, into a mixed-use project with housing. Under the current draft plan, the site could accommodate up to 430 residential units.

“This is not a one-and-done process … because I want to make sure that we do [this project] well,” Mayor Scott Jablow later said. “I don’t think that there’s any appetite among anyone on council to have more than three stories. However, the council was clear that … we wait until we get that housing study back.”

Going down to three-story housing would cut the total residential units by 25%, bringing the new total to around 320 units, according to staff.

There was no formal direction given to staff regarding the Western Gateway and council is waiting for more direction from the housing study or plan before proceeding. It will be at least a few months before the study is ready for the council, according to City Manager Anette Spickard, which alone will take “a lot of debate to come to the final conclusion on.”

The Draft Master Plan, presented from Dig Studio Inc., proposes a maximum of 430 housing units on 11.3 acres, four acres of mixed use and commercial in two development blocks to the west of the Yavapai College campus along State Route 89A, 9.5 acres of community benefit area for possible parks, recreation area and performance space, retaining 10.5 acres as open space and 5.8 acres for development infrastructure and right-of-ways. The Sedona International Film Festival has expressed interest in relocating its theaters to the site.

Another part of the development Vice Mayor Holli Ploog raised was a 400-unit parking garage for the mixed-use area where surface parking is not sufficient for larger development over 80,000 square feet.

Advertisement

“That’s not a city expense that would be where the developer expense would be,” dig consultant Jay Hicks said. “That’s the [developer] basically building their required parking just to park their facility. There’s also been discussion, even on the residential [area,] does it make sense to have a shared parking garage?”

“We’re just in the process of building a garage over 200 and something cars that is humongous and is really controversial in this community,” Ploog said. “I can’t imagine anybody asking for a garage for 400 cars in this space. … That’s a non-starter for me.”

Council provided no direction on the number of housing units or any of the other facilities, all of which will be discussed at multiple future meetings.

Sedona Cultural Park 2.0

City staff met with the ad hoc group Sedona Cultural Park 2.0, which is advocating for reopening the 5,550-seat venue through a three-phase, $21.9 million plan, beginning with a $2 million first phase. The group presented a business plan outlining its vision for the project.

“We have been asking for easily a year; show us a business plan of what that would look like to resurrect the cultural park amphitheater,” Councilman Brian Fultz said. “The only thing I’ve seen we just received, I would call that a statement of aspiration … we should rebuild ours. ‘It’s going to happen in three phases, and need $21 million. We’re not going to ask you for any of it, and you’re going to get tons of tax money. It’s going to be great. You’re going to love it.’ … That’s not a business plan.”

“Fultz was being generous when he called it aspirational. I think it was a puff piece,” Councilman Derek Pfaff said.

Sedona Cultural Park 2.0 President John Bradshaw told the NEWS that the group’s proposal is adequate for now, given the group does not have a memorandum of understanding with the city regarding the property’s future.

“We felt what we gave them was sufficient enough for them to at least go to the next step and formalize something with our group, so that we could be working together and not feel like we’re out there by ourselves with no chance of making this happen,” Bradshaw said.

The draft master plan has a smaller 1,000-seat amphitheater in the northeast corner of the property with a five-acre community park.

Sedona International Film Festival

City Council was receptive to SIFF’s pitch to relocate its entire operation to the Western Gateway. During public comment, SIFF Executive Director Patrick Schweiss said the nonprofit “would like to be the developers of block one and block two,” the mixed-use sections of the proposal along State Route 89A, and is proposing the construction of a 300-seat music and live theater performance venue.

“We are not meant to replace an outdoor amphitheater; our project is completely different,” Schweiss said. “We desperately need a performance space with 300 to 350 seats. The Sedona Performing Arts Center is wonderful … but what’s missing is that ‘sweet spot’ of 300 to 350 seats, which is the size most organizations can realistically fill.”

SOCSD

“I think we need to meet with the [school] board like what we did with the [Sedona] Fire District when talking about their need for a new location for a fire station,” Councilman Brian Fultz said.

Sedona-Oak Creek School District Governing Board President Randy Hawley and Superintendent Tom Swaninger, Ph.D, told the NEWS the district is interested in projects that bring additional family housing, however SOCSD does not currently have a position on the Western Gateway.

“We’ve lost teachers because they couldn’t afford to live here, I’m happy to have a meeting with him and listen to what they have to say,” Hawley said.

Councilwoman Melissa Dunn shared statistics from city staff about first-responders who live within the city, stating that only one of the 26 sworn officers in the Sedona Police Department do so, only five of 87 firefighters in SFD live within the city limits and that only three more reside within SFD boundaries.

“We have 178 city employees; 27 of them live within the city limits, some of them live as far away as Flagstaff,” Dunn said. “[Of] the eight people who support the [Sedona] Community Center, which is one of our service contract providers, only two live inside the city limits. Of the 30 Humane Society [of Sedona] employees, only three live inside the city limits and of the 27 Community Library Sedona employees, only two live inside the city limits. So these are people who we rely on to provide us with other services, and they’re not able to afford to live inside of our city.”

Public Comment

Of the 23 public comments, about six supported the project, while the majority expressed opposition.

The Save Sedona Committee ad hoc filed the “Sedona Cultural Park Preservation Act” with the city clerk on May 22 to gather signatures and send to voters an initiative to “prohibit residential development of any kind or overnight camping or sleeping within the Sedona Cultural Park,” according to measure’s proposed language.

The group’s founder Bill Noonan said the signature gathering is “going well” with the goal of gathering the required 475 signatures in October or November and that he is optimistic about placing the referendum on the Aug. 4, 2026, primary election ballot.

Based on the 3,164 ballots cast in 2024, an initiative requires signatures equal to 15% of those votes, compared to 10% for a referendum. A mayoral recall requires 25%, or 791 signatures in order to meet that threshold.

“We’re supportive of what [Noonan] trying to do,” Bradshaw said. “The main reason is we just want to know what the community wants. Because if the community doesn’t want the cultural park, then there’s no need for us to be spending all the time we’re spending on this. But my gut is telling me that the community is behind the cultural park, and I feel that if we get that confirmation that the city would be a lot more apt to help us get this done.”

The Western Gateway Draft Master Plan is available to read at plansedona.com.

Joseph K Giddens

Joseph K. Giddens grew up in southern Arizona and studied natural resources at the University of Arizona. He later joined the National Park Service in many different roles focusing on geoscience education throughout the West. Drawn to deep time and ancient landscapes he’s worked at: Dinosaur National Monument, Petrified Forest National Park, Badlands National Park and Saguaro National Park among several other public land sites. Prior to joining Sedona Red Rock News, he worked for several Tucson outlets as well as the Williams-Grand Canyon News and the Navajo-Hopi Observer. He frequently is reading historic issues of the Tombstone Epitaph newspaper and daydreaming about rockhounding. Contact him at jgiddens@larsonnewspapers.com or (928) 282-7795 ext. 122.

- Advertisement -