
The size of the Broken Arrow trailhead may double from 2.5 to 4.93 acres after Sedona City Council voted 5- 0 approved the city’s application with Arizona State Parks and Trails OHV $750,000 Grant for a redesign on Aug. 26. Councilwoman Melissa Dunn and Councilman Pete Furman were absent from the Aug. 26 meeting.
Sedona Public Works Director Kurt Harris noted it will likely be a two-year process before any construction could start.
“We would have to bring back to council any discussion about any cost overages beyond the grant amount and there’s no match required for this grant, it will pay for 100% of the cost [of construction],” City Manager Anette Spickard said. “We’re going to try to make it work within the grant amount.”
The city would serve as the primary agency if the funding is awarded, with the U.S. Forest Service providing coordinated oversight. Both governments “feel there is a high probability this application will be awarded,” according to the meeting packet. In addition, the ad hoc Greater Sedona Recreation Collaborative submitted a letter of recommendation for the project and GSRC members discussed it during its July 8 update to council.
The USFS completed its National Environmental Policy Act requirements on March 28 finding the project can be categorically excluded from further analysis after starting its scoping period on Aug. 19, 2024.
Improvements include “a wider paved entrance, vault toilet and time-limited parking for ‘staging,’” the USFS Decision Memo reads. “The purpose of these improvements is to enhance traffic flow; reduce the likelihood of vehicles parking in the nearby neighborhood; improve visitor experience; increase visitor safety and alleviate environmental concerns related to human waste.”
Neighbors said they were concerned the addition of vault toilets would incentivize illegal overnight camping, however the USFS outreach on the topic cited the presence of human waste in the area was because of the lack of restrooms.
“So, they understood the importance of that, and our police department also would come through and patrol this to make sure that there’s no illegal overnight camping,” Spickard said.
The USFS Decision Memo claims “anecdotally, the increase in OHV use has been especially noticeable at Broken Arrow,” along with all other recreational user groups at the trailhead over the last decade.
“It can neither be confirmed or denied that there has been an increase in OHVs at the trailheads,” the city of Sedona’s June 2023 study stated regarding the environmental effects of OHVs.
The first 0.1 miles of Forest Service Road 179F will be paved and widened to allow for better traffic flow between Morgan Road and the trailhead, with the 31-space parking lot surfaced with aggregate and a user-created trail that could be adopted or the construction of a new trail or sidewalk would allow for better pedestrian access from Morgan Road to the trailhead.
“This trail would likely be dirt or gravel but may be upgraded to concrete or pavement in the future,” the decision memo reads. One resident spoke in opposition to the project and cited, among other concerns, that the improvements may contribute to Sedona’s heat island effect.
The decision memo calls for two gates to be constructed on FSR 179F, one near the intersection of Morgan Road.
“A second gate would be placed past the parking lot entrance … [it] would allow drivers to enter the trailhead unimpeded but would allow the [USFS] to prevent entrance to the Broken Arrow Basin,” the memo reads. “This gate would implement temporary wet weather road closures and be needed if managers decide to limit the number of vehicles entering Broken Arrow Basin.”
The USFS memo also calls for time-limited parking for groups staging before riding into the basin. The city sent a request to the USFS on Nov. 2, 2021, for a limited-entry permit system for several trails, including Broken Arrow.
Residents have said they also have an issue with OHV noise from Broken Arrow and the reconfiguration of the trailhead should improve traffic flow and stop riders from staging in front of area homes along Morgan Road — paving the road entrance and adding designated staging areas should reduce this issue.
“Always glad when I can see collaboration be so successful and the collaboration here was not just the federal agency and the city of Sedona, but actual users represented by GSRC and actual residents affected by what goes on there,” Councilwoman Kathy Kinsella said, echoing the council’s sentiment. “So I think the collaboration exhibited here is an example to be followed and admired and applauded.”