Big Park, Little Park water companies seek rate hike, merger

A crew from Southwest Tank and Steel weld support beams on Thursday, April 11, 2024 for a new storage tank for Big Park Water Company’s Well No. 3 on Cathedral Rock Drive. Big Park Water did a complete remodel of the site with upgraded storage capability from 50,000 to 180,000 gallons along with new electrical equipment including a generator for use in case of power outages. David Jolkovski/Larson Newspapers

Big Park Water Company is seeking higher rates from the Arizona Corporation Commission, which, if approved, will increase the monthly water bills for customers of the company that serves about 75% of Village of Oak Creek residents.

An average customer uses 5,252 gallons and pays $37.71. They would see their bill increase 23.5% to 24.32% and pay roughly $10 more per month.

The proposed increase scales by the monthly amount a customer uses. A big Big Park Water customer, like a horse property that uses 45,000 gallons, could pay 70% more.

The final amount is contingent on if the ACC approves the rate case and also approves a separate request to merge Big Park Water with its subsidiary Little Park Water. If the merger goes through it would create “one entity with one new set of rates,” according to the companies’ Jan. 25 rate application to the ACC.

The consolidation would serve about 3,342 customers, with majority being the 3,230 customers of Big Park Water compared to Little Park’s 112 customers, two of which are commercial users.

“Little Park provides water to a majority of the area along Verde Valley School Road all the way to the [Verde Valley] School and then basically, where the asphalt ends,” Big Park Water Operations Manager Nick Gudovic said.

Little Park Water users average 10,581 monthly gallons of water — about twice as much as Big Park customers — and can expect their current bill of $73.50 increase 27.92% and spend $94.02 monthly if the merger fails or will see costs increase $0.74 monthly if the consolidation is approved, according to the ACC.

Big Park Water’s previous rate adjustment process began in 2018, with those prices taking effect in June 2020. “Big Park’s revenues from its utility operations are presently inadequate to provide a fair rate of return on the fair value of its utility plant,” its application read. The company has cited the gamut of economic concerns, from increasing costs of goods and labor, inflation and increasing regulatory standards.

Part of a rate case involves a utility submitting to the ACC a “test year” — a 12-month window of a utility’s financial information — to determine appropriate future rates for customers, and the amount of money it needs to provide a reasonable rate of return.

In its application Big Park Water stated that “the rate of return during the test year was 0.90%, considerably less than the authorized return in the last rate case.”

“Big Park is seeking total annual revenues of $2,504,317 which includes an increase of $535,414, or approximately 27.13% over the adjusted and annualized test revenues of $1,969,903. … Specifically, the increase in annual revenues to provide for recovery of operating expenses and a 7.24% return on rate base is approximately $534,414 excluding rate case expense.”

According to Little Park’s application, it was operating at a loss during its test year with an adjusted operating income of negative $9,504 with its adjusted gross revenue of $176,123.

“Little Park is simply too small to attract capital on its own, and it likely has too small a customer base to continue to absorb the ongoing costs associated with the operation of small, rural water providers,” Gudovic testified to the ACC. “A consolidated Big Park is less likely to need financing surcharges to support debt issuance.”

The ACC application also requests a customer surcharge to recover the companies’ legal costs for submitting its request. The surcharge, set by ACC, would be paid over a planned three-year monthly charge to a customer’s bill.

Gudovic said Little Park Water Company has no staff and relies on Big Park’s staff being wholly owned by Big Park Water, though it operates under separate tax, system and company IDs with ACC requiring separate taxes and water quality reports.

“While I do not oppose the consolidation of the companies, I strongly object to the proposed rate increase. According to the information provided, my bill could increase by as much as [24.32%],” Big Park Water customer Mary Morris wrote to the ACC on June 16. “I know that many of my neighbors, who are also on fixed incomes, would face similar hardships.”

Since 2017, Little Park Water has added 26 new customers or 30%, compared to Big Park’s 47 new connections since 2018, a 1.5% increase.

Submitted written comments referencing Docket No. W-02192A-25-0040 and W-01624A-25-0041 to Arizona Corporation Commission, Consumer Services Section, 1200 W. Washington, Phoenix, AZ, or by submitting comments at azcc.gov by clicking on “Divisions” then “Hearing” and “eFiling Services” and clicking on “Make a Public Comment in a Docket.”

The ACC will hold a hearing starting Oct. 27, at 10 a.m. at ACC headquarters. Public comments will be taken either in person or by phone to (877) 309-3457 and enter passcode 24641845163##

For questions, contact Big Park and/or Little Park Water, by phone at (928) 284-2298, or by email at info@bigparkwater.com.

Joseph K Giddens

Joseph K. Giddens grew up in southern Arizona and studied natural resources at the University of Arizona. He later joined the National Park Service in many different roles focusing on geoscience education throughout the West. Drawn to deep time and ancient landscapes he’s worked at: Dinosaur National Monument, Petrified Forest National Park, Badlands National Park and Saguaro National Park among several other public land sites. Prior to joining Sedona Red Rock News, he worked for several Tucson outlets as well as the Williams-Grand Canyon News and the Navajo-Hopi Observer. He frequently is reading historic issues of the Tombstone Epitaph newspaper and daydreaming about rockhounding. Contact him at jgiddens@larsonnewspapers.com or (928) 282-7795 ext. 122.

Exit mobile version