
Justin Behrman and Jason Metzger are familiar faces from Sedona schools, but they aren’t so recognizable once they don their umpire masks and step behind home plate to make the calls for the Sedona Parks and Recreation Department’s Adult Softball Recreational Leagues weekly Thursday night games, which started on June 12 at Posse Grounds Park.
Behrman “has worked with us for a couple of years now,” Sedona Athletics and Aquatics Supervisor Carmen Brashier said. “He’s done Grasshopper Basketball with us and stays connected on the athletic side with open gym volleyball and basketball, too. Stepping into the umpire role last year was kind of an easy transition for him.”
Brashier added that it was nice to have a familiar figure step into the role after the retirement of Noel Marquis in 2023, who had umpired the games for two decades.
“Justin holds a degree in kinesiology/physical education from Northern Illinois University [earned in 2007] and a Master’s Degree in Educational Leadership,” Behrman’s bio at Sedona Charter School reads, where he works as the financial assistant and athletics director. “He has served in a variety of roles across public education, including alternative school settings, before joining Sedona Charter in 2022, also known as the ‘2nd Happiest Place on Earth.’ Outside of school, Justin enjoys riding his motorcycle, playing golf, staying active and exploring holistic healing practices.”
Behrman relocated to Sedona in 2022. He first picked up a glove in suburban Chicago when he was 6.
“I played for close to 20 years,” Behrman said. “Wow, that sounds like such a long time — holy cow.”
It wasn’t until 2017 or 2018, after realizing his playing days were slowing down, that Behrman found a new way to stay close to the sport he loved: Officiating.
“I couldn’t play as well as I used to,” Behrman said. “But I still wanted to be around the game and have fun.”
In Illinois, Behrman began umpiring games ranging from coed 14-inch leagues to high-level men’s tournaments. He said that he found the transition from player to umpire to be smoother than he had expected, but that one of the challenges was learning to “bad guy sometimes, and making that call that you know that half of the people there are not going to like.”
“For the most part, people respect the calls,” Behrman said. “I think it comes down to being confident in your decision. If there’s any hesitation or uncertainty, that’s when people start to question it. They can sense when you’re not confident, and that’s what they don’t appreciate. They see right through it.”
“At the end of the day, it was always about having fun, which is also what I love about the league here,” Behrman said. “Of course, every once in a while, things got a little competitive.”
“One of my favorite parts about officiating in Sedona has been running into people out and about, at the grocery store, restaurants, wherever, and having them take the time to say they appreciated my effort, which means a lot to me,” Behrman said.
Metzger, an educator of 30 years and a Camp Verde High School English teacher for the past two, has been umpiring in Sedona for several years.
Metzger graduated from Agoura High School in southern California and received a bachelor’s degree in political science from UC Berkeley in 1993 and a master’s degree in education from Northern Arizona University in 2003.
He moved to the Sedona area in the early 1990s and worked at several local schools, including Sedona Sky Academy and Southwestern Academy, as well as coaching soccer, working as an American Youth Soccer Organization commissioner and officiating everything from high school basketball to youth soccer.
“I grew up playing everything, playing baseball, soccer, basketball, and we would just basically play baseball in our neighborhood from morning till night,” Metzger said. “That’s how I fell in love with the game of baseball and became a big fan of the Dodgers who are my team, but I respect the Diamondbacks.”
He and his wife Debbie, who owns a beauty salon in the Village of Oak Creek, have three sons, Max, now in college at Barrett, Arizona State University, Ben an incoming senior, and Luke, heading into ninth grade.
“I married Debbie in 2002 after meeting in 1998 at a pool tournament; she beat me, of course; she was quite a pool shark … and either I lost on purpose and won the date, or that’s the story I’m telling,” Metzger said.
Metzger said that Marquis got him involved in officiating locally about three years ago.
“Noel, who I worked with at Sedona Sky, was a math teacher, I was the principal, and I hired him,” Metzger said. “He got me into [umpiring] when he said the league needed some extra help, so I wanted to support him. Because it’s difficult to find umpires, and if you don’t have them, you don’t have fair games.”
Verde Valley residents interested in joining a softball team can contact Brashier at (928) 282-7098 or cbrashier@sedonaaz.gov for more information. Teams may add players to their roster up to a maximum of 24 until the postseason begins, typically at the end of August.


















