Canyon Mesa Country Club HOA gets Firewise USA sign

Helen Campbell , ch airwoman of the Canyon Mesa Firewise Committee, holds the Firewise USA sign presented to the Canyon Mesa Country Club Homeowners Association on Wednesday, May 7. The Village of Oak Creek community officially joined the national wildfire preparedness program on Nov. 15. Canyon Mesa is the third community in the Village to participate in the program. Photo courtesy of Helen Campbell.

The Canyon Mesa Country Club Homeowners Association, located on the south side of Jacks Canyon Road in the Village of Oak Creek, received a Firewise USA sign on May 7 after beginning to participation the program on Nov. 15.

Canyon Mesa includes 173 lots and 170 townhomes on almost 40 acres and is the third HOA in the VOC to sign up for the program, following Firecliff Community Association and La Barranca II.

“Now the hard work starts, because you have an obligation to do one volunteer hour per year, each homeowner,” Firewise Committee Chairwoman Helen Campbell said. “But since we hire a crew to do all that, we are getting a lot done in a hurry, but there is a lot more to do.”

Firewise USA is a program of the National Fire Protection Association that works with the state of Arizona Department of Forestry and Fire Management to help communities reduce wildfire risk. To participate, communities must form a committee, conduct a wildfire risk assessment, create a three-year action plan and host an outreach event.

“In September, we will be having a meeting in the clubhouse … a lot of people know we are Firewise and are excited,” Campbell said. “Over the summer, I have an arborist coming to do a demonstration of a Firewise [cutting] technique, so that homeowners can see the before and after. A lot of homeowners have the impression that being Firewise means clearcutting and that just simply isn’t the case.”

The recommendations in the HOA’s action plan included installing 1/8-inch metal mesh on home vents to block embers, clearing dead trees and trimming branches up to 10 feet off the ground, mowing native grasses to no more than four inch inches in height and regularly inspecting roofs and gutters. The community’s annual budget for landscaping and fire mitigation is $257,171.

Campbell said that the HOA board decided to join the program after Ralph Stonehocker, a seven-year resident, had his home insurance canceled after the insurance company decided his property carried too much risk. Stonehocker stated that he later found a different company with a similar rate but “the coverage isn’t as good.” His home is located at the south end of Canyon Mesa adjacent to the Coconino National Forest, and is one of about a dozen homes along the foot of Horse Mesa in proximity to the forest.

“That just got me thinking, my goodness sakes, what is going on? So I started making contacts, and that’s when I learned about Firewise,” Campbell said.

Stonehocker said he believed most of the other cancellations in the neighborhood were affecting homes like his near the forest, pointing out that the homeowners across the street from him, who are also with his former insurance company, did not have their policies canceled.

Nick Hastings, an insurance agent with Crest Insurance, said his agency has worked with Canyon Mesa since 2012. The HOA previously carried a master insurance policy covering all buildings in the community, with individual homeowners buying supplementary coverage, but amended its bylaws in July 2021 to require homeowners to insure their units, with the association retaining coverage only for common areas.

“Over the last five years the insurance market in Northern Arizona has been extremely challenging, with many carriers pulling out of the market and all remaining carriers raising rates while reducing coverage,” Hastings said. “The condo and townhouse market for insurance has always been quite limited and the wildfire concerns over the last five to seven years have left no good options for associations like Canyon Mesa.

“If there’s a wildfire, having less vegetation between the forest and your home lowers the chances of fire reaching your property,” Sedona Fire District Deputy Fire Marshal Kirk Riddell said. “The fewer fuels there are, the better your odds of your home surviving a wildfire. Another reason to obtain Firewise accreditation is many people … across Arizona, myself included — have either had their insurance policies canceled or seen their rates go up due to being in a high fire-risk area.”

Riddell visited the HOA and conducted property assessments as part of the Firewise certification.

“As far as wildfire risk goes, the biggest concern I’ve seen is the location of homes that border Forest Service land,” Riddell said of his assessment. “In some cases, there’s only about 10 feet between the forest and the structures, and because that land belongs to the Forest Service, residents can’t clear or manage it themselves. The good news is that most of the homes out there are what we call ‘hardened’ — they have stucco exteriors, class A roofs and fire-resistant windows and doors. These are all key features we look for in the wildland-urban interface to make homes more resilient to wildfire.”

Insurers in Arizona are not required to consider an HOA’s Firewise status when setting rates.

“I’ve definitely seen people that have joined the Firewise program where they’ve had issues just being able to hold insurance, and then after they obtained the recognition, they were at least able to keep their insurance,” DFFM North Zone Prevention Captain Matt Rust said.

Rust added that two other communities in Sedona and the VOC were working to join the Firewise program, including Jordan Park.

The Canyon Mesa action plan stated that the HOA will continue to work with the Forest Service in regards to land contiguous to Canyon Mesa’s southern edge and “continue homeowner education with fuel management practices, fuel evaluation for removal goals and explore opportunities to remove dead and down fuels from the forest bordering Canyon Mesa that creates a risk to our community.”

Joseph K Giddens

Joseph K. Giddens grew up in southern Arizona and studied natural resources at the University of Arizona. He later joined the National Park Service in many different roles focusing on geoscience education throughout the West. Drawn to deep time and ancient landscapes he’s worked at: Dinosaur National Monument, Petrified Forest National Park, Badlands National Park and Saguaro National Park among several other public land sites. Prior to joining Sedona Red Rock News, he worked for several Tucson outlets as well as the Williams-Grand Canyon News and the Navajo-Hopi Observer. He frequently is reading historic issues of the Tombstone Epitaph newspaper and daydreaming about rockhounding. Contact him at jgiddens@larsonnewspapers.com or (928) 282-7795 ext. 122.

Exit mobile version