From July 2014 through August 2015, the Dells Land Use Work Group held 25 meetings to consider possible future uses for the city of Sedona’s surplus land at the Wastewater Reclamation Plant west of the city.
The work group issued its final report, including a minority opinion, in September 2015, but this report was never made public by the city.
Although the report suggested a number of agricultural and recreational uses for the land, its primary finding called for the recreation of elements of the Sedona Cultural Park, including an outdoor performance venue, as the Cultural Park was privately owned at the time.
Majority Vision
The city adopted an effluent management plan in 2014, which called for replacing surface spraying of treated wastewater for irrigation with injection wells that would be used to replenish the city’s aquifer. The abandonment of irrigation as a disposal method was expected to free up approximately 200 of the wastewater plant’s 400 acres of land for potential redevelopment.
Then-City Manager Tim Ernester convened a citizen work group to study possible future uses for the newlyavailable land, which included Rob Adams, Paul Chevalier, Mark DiNunzio, Dena Greenwood, Andrea Houchard, Max Licher, Gerhard Maver, Maria Tonello, Jennifer Wesselhoff, John Wesnitzer and Ernester — after his retirement in February 2015.
The report’s majority vision called for leaving the western half of the property adjacent to State Route 89A largely untouched as a greenbelt in order to “preserve the important view shed from the highway.” Eighty acres were to be reserved for native greenbelt, 15 acres for native plant seed production, 25 acres for vineyards, 20 acres for botanical gardens, 15 acres for parking, 10 acres for an amphitheater and festival grounds, 10 acres for a campground, seven acres for orchards, five acres for a winery, four acres for a research center and three acres for greenhouses.
‘Strong Community Desire’
“The highest ranked land use proposed on the 200 acres is a performing arts amphitheater,” the report stated. “This amphitheater will fulfill the strong community desire for a large outdoor performing arts venue, similar to the one once provided by the original Cultural Park … easily expandable to accommodate more frequent crowds of 500 to 1,500 people, all the way up to 5,000 seats for the rare concert events that might need such a scale.”
The amphitheater at the Sedona Cultural Park, which the city purchased in November 2022, is a scalable performing arts venue with a maximum capacity of 5,350.
The Posse Grounds Pavilion amphitheater was still in development and was not completed until May 2017.
The report further claimed that an amphitheater’s “location at the Dells will preclude any noise conflict with neighboring subdivisions, a problem that has plagued all previous venues within the Sedona city limits and in the Village of Oak Creek, and limited their economic viability.”
A June 7, 2000, letter to the Sedona Red Rock News from realtor John D. Miller noted that noise levels during the Cultural Park’s opening concert reached a maximum of 20 decibels; the park’s permitted maximum was 70 decibels.
The report went on to propose that the amphitheater be tucked into the site’s natural contours, that it maximize audience views of the red rock formations, that parking be integrated into the wooded terrain and screened by trees and that restrooms and concession buildings be “low key,” all of which are features of the existing Cultural Park.
“Widespread support still exists in Sedona for an outdoor amphitheater, as evidenced by the community expressions in subsequent Community Plan amendments,” the authors argued.
The amphitheater was to be located adjacent to “two large multi-purpose fields” that “could be used as festival grounds.” The Cultural Park master plan likewise included festival grounds with a rated capacity of 2,500.

Sustainable Living
The report suggested the creation of a nonprofit organization, the “Red Rock Botanical Gardens and Verde Valley Horticultural and Restoration Institute,” to manage part of the Dells development. The botanical gardens would have combined interpretive trails with gardens devoted to native plants, herbs, medicinal plants and local vegetables.
As for the institute, it was intended to research local ecosystems, develop plans to optimize human land use for conservation and propagate local species and cultivars.
The allocation of 30 acres of the available space to a vineyard, winery and tasting room was mentioned as a further demonstration of sustainability and open space preservation. A vineyard would have allowed reuse of the effluent from the wastewater plant, as well as creating jobs and generating revenue by attracting mature, wellheeled tourists.
The vineyards and gardens were to be associated with a research center that the city was to establish in partnership with “one or more universities.” In addition to studying the best crops and plants for the local climate, the research center’s efforts would have focused on the effects of using water containing “constituents of emerging concern” when growing crops and ornamental plants.
Conversely, the use of the site and treated water for orchards and vineyards was seen as the most suitable agricultural use for treated water from the wastewater plant. The report’s authors noted that planting orchards would also be a nod to Sedona’s agricultural history and its former primary economic activity. They recommended drip rather than spray irrigation for efficiency. The proposed greenhouses, instead of emphasizing organic growing techniques, would have employed hydroponics, pest control, artificial lighting and vertical growing.
The work group’s report called for buildings to make maximum use of active and passive solar energy, recycle waste and water, feature shared common spaces, use nontoxic materials, be earth-integrated or earth-bermed, be smallscale for reduced energy and resource use, and incorporate green roofs and organic shapes. These concepts have yet to be added to Sedona’s formal planning documents, including its building code, land development code and climate action plan.
Tent Camping
The report included a scheme to build a 30 to 40 space campground as part of the project, not to be visible from the amphitheater, on the grounds that the unique uses of the site would attract campers and that there was a shortage of campgrounds in the Verde Valley. The authors argued that the campground would be very attractive to families and thereby serve as an additional educational facility. They speculated that the campground could generate up to $350,000 in annual revenue.
“The development concept proposed for the Dells includes a small cluster of residential buildings that could be used for staff housing, and for short to extended stays for visiting researchers and teachers,” the report also observed.
Beyond this proposal, the report did not consider the use of the Dells property for housing.
Minority Report
Two of the work group’s members — not identified by name in the report — disagreed with the majority’s conclusions and submitted a dissenting opinion that was included in the final document. According to the dissent, the proposed developments were inconsistent with the community plan, with the historic intent to preserve the land as an extension of U.S. Forest Service lands and “with what the Sedona community desires.”
“This land should not be developed,” the minority report stated. “If developed at all, it should be consistent with the citizens’ desires expressed in the 2013 public survey,” which the opinion’s authors claimed supported wildlife viewing areas and hiking trails.
Development, the minority asserted, would interfere with wildlife corridors, while the planting of vineyards and orchards would be a “direct threat to wildlife.” Rendering the Old Lime Kiln Trail inaccessible to equestrians was another concern.
Not a Priority
The Sedona City Council reviewed the work group report at priority-setting meetings in December 2017 and again in January 2019. On both occasions, the council directed staff that pursuing development of the Dells was not a highpriority item.












