As of Monday, Feb. 27, Arizona’s 90 legislators had filed 1,528 bills for consideration during the 2023 legislative session. A few of these will likely be of special interest to Sedona residents, especially those dealing with short-term rentals, local construction projects and proposals to limit access to public records.
Less Than 17,000
The bill that has drawn the most local attention of the session so far is House Bill 2047, introduced by Arizona Rep. Selina Bliss [R-District 1]. HB2047 would amend Arizona Revised Statute §9-500.39 to allow municipalities with populations less than 17,000 to limit the number of vacation rentals and short-term rentals based on a percentage of their total residential structures and to regulate STRs in the same manner as transient lodging.
However, HB2047 will not be moving forward this session due to procedural maneuvering within the legislature.
On Feb. 14, Sedona Deputy City Manager Joanne Keene informed the Sedona City Council that a hearing on the bill, which had been scheduled for the following day, had been canceled, as the bill had been pulled from the committee.
“It wasn’t actually assigned to the committee, which is a procedural way to kill a bill,” Keene explained to the council.
Sedona resident Jennifer Tanner, who has been active in opposing STRs, was more specific. “Speaker [Ben] Toma [R-District 27] is a real estate agent and bowed to the industry when he did not give the bill its first reading, making it impossible to be voted on in the committee,” Tanner said. “And Rep. Bliss did not know about that requirement.”
“I learned of the forces I was against in championing legislation that brings back local control to neighborhood communities and towns,” Bliss said. “Resistance this session came from the objection of the realtors’ professional association as well as the concern of affecting private property rights. With respect to private property owners, I offered an amendment to differentiate properties with three or more dwellings as commercial providers, thereby protecting the private property owners who wanted to rent out a second home. However, this failed to gain traction as well.”
HB2047 would have applied to the smallest 58 of Arizona’s 91 municipalities, whose cumulative population is 323,562 out of a state population of 7,151,502, or 4.5% of the total.
City short-term rental specialist Teresah Arthur was unable to specify at what number the city of Sedona intends to cap the permitted number of STRs if it is able to do so. Keene claimed that the city has not decided on what the limit will be, but confirmed that it does plan to impose a cap, and also expressed the city’s interest in limiting the number of STRs that can be owned by a single person to three.
At the Feb. 14 council meeting, Keene told council members that city staff likewise wanted to support House Concurrent Resolution 2011, Senate Bill 1497, Senate Concurrent Resolution 1032 and SB1193, all of which would repeal §9-500.39, as well as HB2256, which would appropriate $150 million from the state’s general fund to its housing trust fund.
Public Records
HB2808, as introduced, would have required public entities to respond to public records requests within five business days and imposed a fine of up to $5,000 for each instance of noncompliance. Current law only requires public bodies to respond to records requests “promptly,” without setting a time frame, and does not penalize them for noncompliance. The bill was subsequently amended to increase the maximum time period for public bodies to respond to requests to 15 days.
As of Feb. 27, 92 individuals had signed up to express support for the bill via the legislature’s Request to Speak system, almost all of whom stated that they were private citizens.
Forty-three individuals had registered to express opposition to the bill, almost all of whom indicated that they represented cities and towns including the municipalities of Chandler, Prescott, Scottsdale, Goodyear, Phoenix, Mesa, Maricopa, Flagstaff, Yuma, Mohave County, Santa Cruz County, the Arizona Association of Counties, the League of Arizona Cities and Towns, the Arizona Newspapers Association and the city of Sedona.
Sedona will be represented in its opposition by Keene.
“From the city of Sedona’s perspective, the current statute is working. We do our best to reply within 48 hours of a request and respond as quickly as possible,” Keene stated, claiming that the bill amounted to “bringing a statute from Illinois to fix an issue that may not be an issue in Arizona.”
“Obviously, this is a big burden on cities, towns, and counties,” Keene had previously told council on Feb. 14. Councilwomen Jessica Williamson and Kathy Kinsella similarly expressed their opposition to the bill.
The Arizona Court of Appeals ruled in the 2008 Phoenix New Times vs. Arpaio public records lawsuit against the then-Maricopa County sheriff that “if public entities could be excused from providing public records merely by being inattentive to requests, then access to the records would be easily frustrated.”
Section 1.A.2 of the bill explicitly includes the state in the scope of the legislation, not just local governments.
Roadwork
HB2097, introduced by Bliss and Arizona Rep. Quang Nguyen [District 1] and Arizona Sen. Ken Bennett [R-District 1], would appropriate $18.4 million from the state’s general fund for improvements to State Route 89, including the construction of another roundabout between Road 3 North and Road 5 North in Chino Valley. This funding will be dependent on the town of Chino Valley raising $2.045 million in matching funds.
District 1’s legislators have also proposed HB2098 and a companion, SB1169, to appropriate $6,321,360 to the town of Clarkdale for the construction of a new vehicle bridge over the Bitter Creek wash and the conversion of the existing bridge for pedestrian and cycle traffic.
Father of Waters
SB1392, introduced by Sen. Sine Kerr [R-District 25], would appropriate $10 million to create a state park at the headwaters of the Verde River.
The Verde River rises in Paulden, where its headwaters are impounded by a dam built by the Works Progress Administration around 1937 to create Sullivan Lake. The lake was intended for hunting and fishing use, but rapidly silted up during World War II, when it was not maintained. It is located on a 132-acre parcel currently owned by Del Rio Springs Loan Partners LLC that is zoned agricultural and had an estimated full cash value of $1,723 for the 2023 tax year.
Staffers’ Choice
Keene presented the council with a number of other staff recommendations regarding bills the city should support or oppose. The council accepted these recommendations almost without comment.
- Keene said that city staff intended to oppose HB2061, which would repeal the sales tax on food for home consumption, saving Arizonans an estimated $182.9 million in fiscal year 2024. Keene argued for opposing the bill on the grounds that it would diminish local control.
- Both Keene and members of the council spoke against SB1170, prohibiting the use of unmonitored boxes for depositing ballots, and HB2307, requiring all votes to be tabulated by hand in local elections and prohibiting tabulating machines.
- City staff plan to stay neutral on SB1011, which would allow candidates for council elections to indicate their political party registration on the ballot.
- Keene was keen to secure the council’s backing for city support of SB1189, which would extend the lifespan of the Municipal Tax Code Commission for another four years. She claimed that for cities and towns to have to work directly with the state instead of the commission on tax issues would be “a nightmare.”
Also Running
Other bills of note:
- SCR1008, recognizing April 1, 2023, as Assyrian New Year.
- SB1112, prohibiting the Chinese Communist Party from owning property in Arizona. This may be incompatible with both Article I, Section 9, Clause 3 and the Due Process Clause of the U.S. Constitution.
- SB1297, registering residents to vote automatically when they renew their driver’s licenses.
- SB1424, amending A.R.S. §36-681 and §36-685 to prohibit mask-wearing or COVID-19 vaccination requirements by businesses as well as government entities.
- SB1636, restoring voting rights automatically on final discharge from prison or completion of probation.
- HCR2007, calling for the amendment of the state constitution to prohibit slavery or involuntary servitude without exception.
- HCR2029, calling for the repeal of Arizona’s personal income tax.
- HB2179 through HB2183, adding substantial restrictions to firearms purchases. The most significant of the five bills is HB2182, which would ban private firearms sales between individuals except for members of certain privileged groups.
- HB2224, allowing homeschooled students to take college admissions tests at no cost.
- HB2523, requiring students to participate in the Pledge of Allegiance to the United States flag.
- HB2560, requiring the publication of a list of registered voters’ names, ages and addresses before an election; a list of the same information for those who voted in an election after the election; and images of all ballots cast during an election.
- HB2741, making the transfer of any part of a dead kangaroo a misdemeanor.
- HB2756, prohibiting cities or towns from reducing paramilitary budgets.
- HB2799, creating an open statewide primary election to replace partisan primaries.
















