45.4 F
Sedona
Tuesday, November 17, 2026

City awaits water tank hearing3 min read

The city of Sedona is still waiting for the next step regarding a lawsuit filed against it earlier this year.
The lawsuit centers around a deciĀ­sion by the city to allow a 1.5-million-gallon water tank to be built in a resiĀ­dential area near the intersection of State Route 179 and Mallard Drive.

Vincent McGeary, an attorney who lives on Cathedral Rock Trail, filed a complaint for special action in March with the Coconino County Superior Court.

The case has not yet been heard nor has a date been set. According to Assistant City Attorney Shelley Cutts, the city is waiting for the courts to set up a telephonic conference between the judge, the city and McGeary.

ā€œNot much has happened since Mr. McGeary’s filing,ā€ she said. ā€œRight now we’re just waiting to have a date set for the conference call.ā€
By the 4-1 vote, the Sedona Planning and Zoning Commission approved a Conditional Use Permit request from Arizona Water Company last October. An appeal can be made in writing within 15 days of the commission’s decision, which McGeary did.

In January, Sedona City Council heard an appeal regarding the construction of the water tank. By a unanimous vote, council voted to uphold planning and zoning’s deciĀ­sion, thus denying McGeary’s appeal.Ā  Now, he is requesting the court nullify and void the CUP.

Advertisement

In his filing, McGeary states he will be impacted by the construction of the industrial facility, including but not limited to increased traffic, noise and dust caused by excavation and construction activities. In addition, he feels he will be impacted due to the elimination of residential lots in the district in which the property is located and in the form of diminuĀ­tion in property value during the construction and thereafter.

He also alleges that city staff was biased in terms of their desire to see a water tank built in that area.

ā€œPrior to Arizona Water Company’s purchase of the propĀ­erty, the city desired the construcĀ­tion of a water storage and treatment facility on or near the property,ā€ his court filing states. ā€œOn information and belief, prior to AWC’s purchase of the property, the Director and Department [Community Development] knew of AWC’s plan to purchase the property for the purpose of building the plant. The department communicated to AWC its support of AWC’s plan to purchase the property and construct the plant, and aided and abetted the AWC in its effort to secure the CUP.ā€

He wrote that the council and commission failed to make the required findings before denying the appeal and granting the CUP, as required by city code.

ā€œThe council acted arbitrarily and capriciously in approving the actions of the commission despite the commission’s failure to make findings required by LDC,ā€ McGeary wrote.

City Attorney Robert Pickels said in May that the complaint alleges that the city failed to make requisite findings of fact in arriving at its decision to approve the permit for the water tank. Also, the complaint alleges city staff acted as an advoĀ­cate for Arizona Water Company in presenting the application to the commission and council.

ā€œThe city has denied that those allegations are true,ā€ he said.Ā  Pickels has said both the commisĀ­sion and the council were presented with a comprehensive evaluation of the application and the staff opinion regarding the requisite findings of fact. Both took action to approve the application after having reviewed the information presented by staff and stating that the application was deemed to be in compliance.

ā€œThe standard on review will be whether the commission or council based their decision on something less than credible evidence,ā€ he said.

Ron Eland

Ron Eland has been the assistant managing editor of the Sedona Red Rock News for the past seven years. He started his professional journalism career at the age of 16 and over the past 35 years has worked for newspapers in Nevada, Hawaii, California and Arizona. In his free time he enjoys the outdoors, sports, photography and time with his family and friends.

- Advertisement -