Questions arise over SOCSD’s hiring of PR firm

In August, Sedona-Oak Creek School District hired a new public relations firm after what school officials stated was a formal search process. Yet the three firms not hired say they were never contacted by SOCSD, raising questions about whether the information on the forms may have been falsified by school officials.

According to the Arizona Attorney General’s office, the legal consequences could be significant for any school district that falsifies information on an oral quote form. If an audit reveals suspicion and reports it to the Auditor General, the Arizona State Board of Education could then recommend withholding 10 percent of state aid to the district.

On Monday, Nov. 30, Sedona-Oak Creek School District Superintendent David Lykins advised the Sedona Red Rock News to send him an email, lodging a formal request for the oral quote form used to retain the services of the Kur Carr Group public
relations firm for a contracted amount of $20,000.

As of press time, the NEWS has not received a response to this request, but on Dec. 3 Heather Hermen — a local district parent who had filed a public records request along the same lines — forwarded the materials.

“Because it was apparent that the total value of any proposed services would be less than $50,000, the Business Office obtained verbal price quotations,” SOCSD Finance Director Colleen McCabe Toscano stated. “Attached are my handwritten notes of the request for quotations and the response of the contacted vendors. To assist you in interpreting the notes, I have prepared a typed explanation of those notes.”

SOCSD Claims to Have Gotten Four Quotes

The two-page form provided — an “Oral/Written Quote Form” generated by the SOCSD Purchasing Department — documents a process wherein Toscano interviewed three vendors and left a voice mail with a fourth on Aug. 6 and 10. All communications appear to have been verbal. Toscano’s notes of the interviews — including whom she spoke to and the rationale for the final decision to retain the Kur Carr Group — amount to all information provided by the district.

“By law, you’re not required to do a formal request for proposal as long as it doesn’t meet $100,000,” Toscano said Dec. 4.

Asked if the vendors would confirm that she had contacted them as documented in the quote form, Toscano added, “I would imagine, yeah. I contacted all of them.”

On Thursday, Dec. 3, however, the NEWS had inquired with the three Phoenix-area candidate vendors, speaking to the individuals specifically listed on the district’s quote form.

Yet Three Firms Say They Never Spoke to SOCSD

According to Toscano’s notes, Zion and Zion advertising agency was not retained for services by the district because it “could not provide an estimate of cost without scheduling a meeting to go over the details, size and immediate needs of our organization. Vendor preferred to meet in person and based on availability and estimated time to research and prepare a response after meeting, services would not be executed/begin within the time lines required by the district.”

Zion and Zion President Eric Zion said, “I can’t ever recall saying to someone, ever” that his company could not make a date work with a client’s needs. He added that it was “within the realm of possibility” that Toscano had contacted him, but he did not recall the name and added that Zion and Zion does not have “so many incoming clients” that he would not recall talking with someone in a school district in Sedona.

According to Toscano’s notes, a representative of the Up Agency never responded to Toscano’s voice mail.

Of this claim, Up Agency President Stacy Pearson reported, “No, sir. There are no voice messages from a 928 number” between Aug. 6 and 10, the dates specified on the Toscano’s form. Moreover, Pearson said she did not recall having heard from SOCSD outside of those dates.

According to Toscano, BJ Communications was not retained for services because “their pricing would vary depending on scope of work, anywhere between $3,500-$15,000 per month. Vendor would require 50 percent paid up-front for any immediate responses/crisis work. Additional hourly rates would apply to crisis work as well.”

Asked if she recalled talking to anyone from SOCSD, BJ Communications President Sara Fleury said, “No, I don’t.”

Concerning the notes Toscano took about the alleged interview, Fleury added, “Yeah, that sounds accurate; I just don’t know that I ever heard from a school district in Sedona.”

According to Toscano, the district chose the Kur Carr Group “based on a combination of low quote, no up-front/prepaid costs required, and their availability to timely begin services to best meet the needs of the district.”

On Dec. 7, Kur Carr Group President Steve Carr said that he did not feel comfortable discussing the specific content of the interview that took place between him and Toscano, but added that it was a “standard process,” including a face-to-face meeting with Toscano to discuss the district’s desire to develop a comprehensive “marketing and public relations strategy.”

Carr is also employed by the Sedona International Film Festival. According to Carr, his firm acquires most of its clients through referral.

‘At Least One of Them Should Remember Us’

SOCSD Governing Board member Bobbie Surber expressed doubt about the process used to retain the Kur Carr Group, calling it an “insufficient process” that should have involved lengthy interviews.

“It’s not four quick phone calls asking what the price would be. I’ve never heard of hiring a public relations firm by just asking how much it is,” Surber said, adding that she would be filing a request to add a discussion about the oral quote process to the January governing board meeting agenda. “I’m not going to let this go. What were we doing?”

Concerning the fact that three out of four vendors could not recall speaking to Toscano, Surber said, “It’s more than weird — let’s be honest about this. At least one of them should remember us …. At the very least, we didn’t do our due diligence. At the worst, we fabricated.”

According to Surber, conducting the quote solely verbally also raises red flags. In the past, Surber explained, the district has always received written materials from vendors following their interviews.

On Dec. 7, Lykins said that the Kur Carr Group met his requirements for a public relations firm — namely, that Carr could write press releases and provide “timely and accurate support in communicating with the public.” Moreover, as the district suffers from the lack of a dedicated communications specialist, Carr would be able to assist in producing a more “formalized plan” to market district schools.

“I also wanted someone with a passion for education,” Lykins said.

According to Carr, most of Kur Carr Group’s clients “are 501(c)(3) nonprofit social service and arts organizations,” including a “number of educational institutions.” Prior to working with SOCSD, however, the Kur Carr Group did not feature school districts among its clients.

Asked for a comment concerning the fact that three out of four vendors could not recall speaking to Toscano, Lykins answered, “Right. I can’t respond to that …. This was six to seven months ago. Would they remember every call they received? …. You’re kidding, right?”

Lykins added that there was “no doubt” in his mind that Toscano had contacted the vendors and asserted that the district had “met the threshold of the letter of the law …. We’re doing what we’re supposed to be doing.”

Despite inquiries by phone and email and in the district office on Dec. 7, Toscano did not respond for additional comment by press time.

 

Zachary Jernigan can be reached at 282-7795 ext. 125 or zjernigan@larsonnewspapers.com 

Larson Newspapers

Exit mobile version