45.8 F
Sedona
Wednesday, November 18, 2026

District OKs restructure research5 min read

Ten Big Park Community School parents, guardians and teachers stood before the Sedona-Oak Creek School District Governing Board during the board’s regular public meeting Tuesday, Dec. 1, with one unified voice, encouraging the board not to restructure their school nor West Sedona School.

Approximately two hours later, the board voted unanimously to give Superintendent David Lykins the authority to research a plan to restructure the district’s “educational delivery” and deliver a cost analysis and timeline. According to Lykins, the term “restructuring” does not reflect a limited focus on school organization: Instead, the entire district, from administration down, would be subject of research for restructuring.

Prior to doing so, however, board members heard from Arizona School Boards Association Director of Leadership Development Karen Loftus, who presented a report on two recent community forum events meant to address an upcoming reduction in state funding — the same forums that resulted in restructuring becoming the district’s top research priority.

The second forum, a roundtable discussion facilitated by Loftus, became the subject of an extended exchange between Loftus and board member Bobbie Surber, who was absent from the Nov. 7 event.

Surber, after enquiring as to whether board members invited to the roundtable were encouraged to listen or actively participate, said that she had heard a “repetitive theme” during her recent conversations with parents and district staff — namely, the expectation that board members would simply listen, as opposed to taking part.

Advertisement

Loftus responded that though she “literally wasn’t at every table,” board members were allowed to participate but “were not driving conversation.”

Noting the presence of so many Big Park constituents, Surber asked, “Where did the idea of restructuring Big Park come from? …. Why is this belief out there?”

Loftus answered that many individuals came into the first forum, Oct. 15, with a preconceived notion that Big Park might close, but failed to account for items within the packet forum organizers provided to the second forum’s participants. First among the suggested topics of discussion in that document was restructuring of district schools.

“I don’t envy the work you have now,” Loftus said concerning the possibility of restructuring. “How much support can you all garner?”

Lykins asked for a move to approve his proposal for conducting research into options for restructuring the district and deliver a cost analysis and timeline. Board member Zachary Richardson asked for clarification that a yes vote was only an approval for research — not a substantive move toward restructuring.

Lykins responded that he was seeking approval “to do our jobs.”

Richardson sought clarification a second time. “So …. just research.”

Surber — the evening’s most vocal board member — expressed disappointment that the community had not been invited to be part of the research process and encouraged Lykins to include them. Echoing Richardson, she sought additional clarification that the approval to conduct research was all Lykins sought.

“Let me read it again,” Lykins answered. He read slowly through his proposed move for action a third time, reiterating that a yes vote would only be an approval of research to be presented to the board during its January meeting.

Despite voting for research along with the rest of the board, Surber said that she thought it was a mistake not to include “how we’re going to involve our stakeholders.” She called for the public to have access to the same information as the board, and encouraged “strategic, ongoing communication.”

Following the vote, board members Richardson and John D. Miller discussed possible action to direct the superintendent to amend the order of the agenda, placing the call to the public at the tail-end of public meetings — linking, according to both board members, the call to the public with future agenda items.

Both Surber and board member Karen McClelland said they would not support the change.

“Part of our job is to know what people think,” McClelland said.

“The least we can do is make sure that process is as convenient as possible,” Surber said.

Richardson responded, saying that he does not believe “five or six people” represent the entire community, and that to really know the public’s perspective board members “have to go out in the community.”

Surber answered that there is “no other legal process” that allows the entire board to hear from the public at once. “To even suggest that we’re going to make it even harder for the community to speak — it’s the wrong message …. To ask families out here to stay well past dinner, well past when their children’s homework should be done, we’ll receive even less communication.”

Richardson said that, should they move the call to the public, the newspaper would spin it to say “we don’t want to talk to the community,” and suggested tabling the action item for a later meeting.

Ultimately, no vote took place.

Approval of Lykins’ Performance Pay

On Tuesday, Dec. 1, the Sedona-Oak Crek School District Governing Board voted unanimously to approve Superintendent David Lykins performance pay, an amount of $7,200. This contracted amount, contingent upon the superintendent’s completion of three goals — a teacher mentoring program, a qualitative assessment program and a communications plan — was voted into effect during the 2014-15 school year, resulting in a total salary compensation of $127,200.

SOCSD Governing Board member Karen McClelland clarified that the $7,200 is not “extra pay,” but money written into Lykins’ contract. According to McClelland, to deny it to him would be restricting his salary.

Though board member Bobbie Surber voted yes along with her four peers, she entered into record that her decision to approve the performance pay had already been agreed upon should Lykins fulfill his contractual obligations. “The argument whether we should or shouldn’t is out of our hands,” she said, but also added that the superintendent was under no obligation to keep the money and could donate it back to underfunded district schools.

Elaborating Dec. 3, Surber stated, “Our administration cost continues to rise in our district, which defies logic in the face of our unbelievable budget challenges — not to mention paying our teachers the lowest wages in the Verde Valley.”

Larson Newspapers

- Advertisement -