A mystery that has spanned the millennia has finally been solved.
The Rotary Club of Sedona’s bell was stolen. The exact year of the heist is unclear, but 1968 seemed to ring a bell for the informant. The lifted item was used to start meetings and no doubt left a considerable delay as club members frantically searched for the instrument.
Then, as mysteriously as it left, it reappeared a few weeks later.
The culprit would get away with the crime and the case faded into history.
However, one man knew who dunnit.
The bell was held hostage by local Lions Club member and rector at St. Andrew’s Episcopal Church, the Rev. Robert Greene.
According to current rector Mary Piotrowski, a youth member of the church at the time was privy to the location of the bell and the circumstances surrounding its whereabouts. He was sworn to secrecy by Greene for decades, however, until Greene’s recent death when the oath was lifted.
Greene had moved to Texas as his health diminished, previously living in Prescott for a time as well, she said.
“[The heist] came as a total surprise to me,” Piotrowski said. “He was a really funny old guy.”
Piotrowski said that Greene was like the “Pied Piper” for kids at the congregation and was quite active in the community.
“He’s a hard guy to forget,” said Serge Wright, Lions member since 1971 and optometrist at Sedona Eye Care. Though he missed the theft by a few years, he knew Greene well as a Lion and wasn’t surprised to hear that Greene pushed the envelope with this kind of prank.
According to Wright, the theft of Rotary’s bell was an extension of a tradition among Lions chapters. Lions members are welcome to visit any club meeting and often would, and when able, also steal the neighboring chapter’s bell, hold it ransom and wait for the other chapter to show and pay to take it back. Wright said the tradition has somewhat died off over the past 15 years.
“We did that for quite a few years,” he said. “I’d expect pastor Greene to take it as far as he could.”
Wright fondly remembered how Greene led the club in prayer before meals. Greene would switch it up a couple times a year from the more serious tone of giving thanks to the simple “rub-a-dub-dub, thanks for the grub. Go, God, go.”
“He was a very interesting gentleman and we enjoyed having him in our club.”
Greene served St. Andrew’s parish from 1968 to 1974. He came to town with his wife and also preached at St. Thomas and oversaw the building of the St. Andrew’s church.
No Rotary club member from the period could be reached.
Could there be a revitalization of the prank? Ask not for whom the bell tolls, it could toll for thee.