45.8 F
Sedona
Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Forum’s big questions unanswered3 min read

Carolyn Martin took a picture of the second comment card she submitted during Sedona-Oak Creek School District’s recent community forum. According to Martin, her questions — concerning the withdrawal of her child from Big Park Community School — were never read aloud. Other parents came forward following the forum to express concerns about the panel not addressing their concerns.
Photo courtesy Carolyn Martin

Following the community forum facilitated by Arizona School Boards Association Director of Leadership Development Karen Loftus on behalf of Sedona-Oak Creek School District on Thursday, Oct. 15, a number of district parents shared their impressions of the event with the Sedona Red Rock News.

The forum, organized by SOCSD Superintendent David Lykins to address an upcoming four-year reduction of funding due to diminishing class enrollment, featured addresses by Yavapai County School Superintendent Tim Carter, SOCSD Finance Director Colleen Toscano and Lykins, followed by an hour-long question and answer session.

Attendees were asked to submit their questions and suggestions on comment cards, which were then passed to Loftus to read.

Former Big Park Community School parent Carolyn Martin submitted a question about why she had not been contacted for input concerning her choice to remove her child from the school. When her question was not answered, she submitted a second comment card. Loftus said that the question had already been asked and turned to Lykins for a confirmation that he had contacted every parent who had chosen to withdraw from Big Park. Lykins answered that he had.

“I can name four other families that left Big Park for reasons that are not being acknowledged. None of these parents have been contacted,” Martin said Monday, Oct. 19, adding that even though all comment cards appeared to be taken into consideration the forum did not encourage direct and honest communication. “It was clear that the questions were being pre-read by Karen Loftus. It was also clear that they did not address all the questions …. It’s tragic.”

Advertisement

A parent with three grade school- and high school-aged children, Amy Montgomery sat in attendance hoping to “leave feeling more optimistic” but did not. While offering praise to the district and the ASBA for conducting the forum in an efficient and professional manner, she did not feel as though her concerns were properly addressed.

“I left with many more questions and a feeling of more skepticism and upcoming problems,” Montgomery explained Oct. 19. “I submitted three questions to the panel. Only one was addressed. All three questions were directed toward Dave Lykins.”

Parent Heather Hermen praised the effort that went into the forum as well as the informative nature of the addresses, stating Oct. 16 and 18, “While most of the information, if not all, was a repeat for myself and others in attendance, it was clear the information was needed. I heard Councilwoman Jessica Williamson, sitting behind me, voice out loud her surprise about the lack of funding in the state and mention it’s a legislation issue. So, people were educated and informed.”

Despite her endorsement of the forum’s organization, Hermen also confirmed Martin and Montgomery’s impressions, stating that submitted questions were not being addressed: “My concern lies with the fact that I showed up with questions in hand and not one of them was asked by the moderator …. They didn’t give a good explanation at the forum, nor the board meeting before to explain how they would choose the questions.”

To read the full story, see the Wednesday, Oct. 21, edition of the Sedona Red Rock News.

Larson Newspapers

- Advertisement -