The Sedona Fire District Governing Board voted to approve a request for proposals put forth by the district’s newly-formed audit committee, but did so without having seen the contract referred to in the proposal.
SFD board members voted to approve the RFP during their Jan. 26 regular meeting. Members of the public were not allowed to speak at the recent meeting due to changes in SFD policy which allow the public an opportunity to speak at monthly work sessions rather than regular meetings. The board met for an executive session prior to the start of the meeting.
Bill Whittington, contracted attorney for SFD, told those at the meeting he was asked to review the RFP while the board met for their executive session. The RFP is part of an independent audit proposed by board members to look at cost-saving measures within the district and headed by former SFD board candidate Joe Demme. Demme, who ran on a slate with board Chairman Dave Blauert and member Phyillis Erick, lost in the election.
Whittington asked about the whereabouts of a sample contract when it came to insurance portions of the RFP, among a number of other questions.
“If you approve this now, you will be doing so without having seen it,” Whittington told board members. “You’re about to approve a contract you’ve never seen, nor will you see, until the proposals come in, if you do this,” Whittington said.
SFD Governing Board Clerk Charles Christensen amended his original RFP motion to include changes suggested by Whittington, and included that a contract be provided to Whittington, but asked board members to still approve the RFP during the meeting.
Blauert, board member Craig Dible, and Christensen voted to approve the RFP. Board member Ty Montgomery voted against approving the RFP. Erick was absent.
“I’m aware of the contract. I have seen the basic one that has come in. I don’t know if Mr. Demme has,” Christensen said.
Demme said the audit committee prepared a “standard format contract” that would be submitted to Whittington for approval.
“That contract will also be provided to respondents and respondents can sit down and negotiate that agreement with us, with the approval of Mr. Whittington. However, as it states in the request for proposal, should they not agree to the terms and conditions that Mr. Whittington or the board would approve, they would be disqualified from the bid process,” Demme said.
Christensen told those at the meeting the audit committee consisted of an attorney and a number of accountants. He said he was satisfied with the RFP document.
“I was assigned the task of assembling a committee of five to establish a request for proposals for the upcoming forensic, or management, audit. They have prepared this document to go out,” Christensen said.
He added the RFP complies with the district’s standards.
come out and the vendor will be chosen,” Christensen said.
Montgomery said he was not comfortable voting on a nine-page RFP he had not seen. Montgomery was not present for an audit committee meeting Jan. 25. Christensen invited Montgomery to read the document during the Jan. 26 meeting after he made the motion.
Demme declined to provide an idea on what the board’s proposed audit would cost the district to prepare and complete. The proposed audit would be independent of audits already conducted within SFD.
“I’ve heard comments that these audits would be very substantial in cost, but until such time as the consultants review the RFP, I think it would not be prudent to throw out a number,” Demme said.
