The Sedona Fire District Governing Board ruled 3-2 there will be no salary increases whatsoever for the 2010-2011 fiscal year.
By freezing all salaries, the fire district will save $145,000.
SFD Fire Chief Nazih Hazime accused the Governing Board of micromanaging him.
The freezes include longevity and merit wages. Longevity wages are for employees with 10 or more years experience with the district.
Board member Bert Berkshire brought this item before the board at the Wednesday, Feb. 25, board budget workshop.
Board member Charles Christensen said the public is looking at them through a magnifying glass and he thinks salaries should be frozen.
Christensen added he thinks salary freezes should have been implemented a long time ago.
Board member Liza Vernet vehemently opposed freezing salaries.
She said SFD employees have families, mortgages and other obligations, so they rely on these funds.
“I do not look at it as a raise. It’s a step,” she said, adding the board should wait until it knows the impacts it will cause.
She said she could not vote for this without additional information and urged the board to wait.
Board member Donald Harr said SFD is fortunate it does not belong to a city since most Arizona communities are laying off employees and reducing salaries.
SFD Fire Marshal Will Loesche said he took on additional work for a position not filled, and now he is hearing his salary will decrease by $1,500 for longevity purposes.
“You are giving me more work, and you are taking away [compensation],” Loesche said.
Berkshire said he is not proposing novice employees make the same salary as an experienced worker.
Assistant Fire Chief Terry Keller said he feels bad for other communities and cities, but added Sedona should not follow their lead.
If SFD does follow what larger entities are doing, it will result in experienced employees leaving the district because larger agencies tend to recover sooner, Keller said.
Vernet said freezing salaries is way too premature with no basis.
“You are making drastic changes to the district, and I find it outrageous,” she said.
Hazime said it is important to know how the district is doing, and added it might be important to look at what other agencies are doing.
“I feel I am being micromanaged,” he said.
The question of whether longevity raises would be included in the salary freezes was asked, and Business Director Karen Daines said those raises are considered bonuses.
“A bonus is not salary,” Berkshire said.
Board Chairman Ralph Graves disagreed.
“It’s a pay cut. It’s part of their wages,” Graves said. “I still look at it like we are cutting wages.”
The board also voted 3-2 against looking at an overtime reduction of 25 percent, with Christensen, Graves and Vernet voting against it.
Berkshire, who proposed the item, said the 25 percent was only a goal, not a mandate and he thinks all overtime should be approved by a battalion chief.
Christensen said the 25 percent proposal was too speculative to consider.
The Governing Board tabled whether new fire district employees should be required to live in the Verde Valley.
