Warning: include(/var/www/rrnweb/includes/joomla_init.php): failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /home2/rrnews/public_html/templates/redrocknews1.5/index.php on line 328

Warning: include(): Failed opening '/var/www/rrnweb/includes/joomla_init.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/opt/php54/lib/php') in /home2/rrnews/public_html/templates/redrocknews1.5/index.php on line 328

Search

Loading

Breaking News:

Close

Online Poll

What is the biggest chore in your spring cleaning?

Sponsored By:

Tlaquepaque Village

Film critic Lyons discusses movies

Film critic Lyons discusses movies

Before he became a nationally-known film critic — with 15,000 reviews under his belt — Jeffrey Lyons had a childhood a kid could only dream of, from learning about bullfighting...

The Sedona Fire District Governing Board decided to go a different direction with its newly formed audit committee after bids came in, which may have had something to do with it.

The wife of the audit committee’s chairman, Joe Demme, works for one of three firms that put in a bid for the contract with SFD.

 

When the Governing Board opened sealed envelopes from the audit committee members, the anonymous votes indicated each of them selected SM McGladrey, the firm Demme’s wife works for. Demme did not vote.

 

The bid from SM McGladrey was for $168,910 while the bids from the other two firms were $65,000 and $62,000. SM McGladrey’s bid was also late.

We found out Demme’s wife worked for an auditing firm from him. He mentioned it at one of the first audit committee meetings before the bids came. Demme later said his wife wouldn’t be directly involved with the audit.

We sat on the information, thinking committee members would see the blatant conflict of interest for the firm to even bid.

However, when the proposals came in, one of which was from SM McGladrey, it was clear to us the ethics violation wasn’t clear to them.

If Demme thought his wife’s firm was the best for the job, he should have resigned from his position as chairman and left the committee altogether.

Then, the firm would have stood on its own merits, even with a price tag of more than double the others.

After sitting on the information Demme gave us at the beginning of the process, we broke the story before the Governing Board planned to vote on it so residents would be aware of all the facts before the meeting. We assumed if Demme announced the information at an audit committee meeting, then the board itself was already aware.

At the next meeting, no action was taken.

On Wednesday, March 23, the board announced — after revealing who the audit committee selected — it would be going in a different direction with the audit and audit committee altogether.

The board made the right ethical decision by not following the committee’s recommendations and hiring a firm that presented an obvious conflict of interest.

Whether the decision would have been made if the story hadn’t appeared on the front page of the Sedona Red Rock News will never be known. However, the board should be commended for not going down that road regardless of what steered it in the right direction.

As far as the new audit committee is concerned, Demme should recuse himself from serving on the committee if he believes his wife’s firm will be bidding.

The committee, staff and firms that bid wasted time and energy only for the project to be killed. This time, let’s follow all the rules and save everybody a little time and money.


Leave your comments

0
terms and condition.

People in this conversation

  • Heading R direction

    Now that the board is starting to make common sense decisions maybe they can ask the Chief management Staff and crews to sit down and work on a solution of a sensible budget that could be agreed on. Come on SFD Fire board show them you want to change and stop waisting money!!!!

Other Headlines

Rainy weekend may cause flooding, USFS warns
Rainy weekend may cause flooding, USFS warns

Rain and snow showers are possible mainly from the Mogollon Rim northward. The area could see 1.0 to [ ... ]

Airport officials updating plan
Airport officials updating plan

The Sedona-Oak Creek Airport Authority is in the process of updating its 20-year master plan, which  [ ... ]

More News

Latest Sports

Verde Valley Vipers take soccer cup in OT win

Verde Valley Vipers take soccer cup in OT win

Kevin Beltran and Carlos Lattanzi, both of Sedona, teamed up for the game-winning overtime goal Sunday, Feb. 15, as the Verde Valley Vipers soccer team took home the Crossroads Cup. The...

Sedona Weather

Cloudy

44°F

Sedona, AZ

Humidity: 65%
Wind: S at 12 mph
Sunday
Rain
43°F / 50°F
Monday
Rain
35°F / 45°F
Tuesday
Showers
28°F / 47°F

Sedona Gas Prices

Lowest Gas Prices in Sedona
Sedona Gas Prices provided by GasBuddy.com