Pro & Con Arguments on Proposition 400
The following is an opinion piece in favor of Proposition 400, Sedona’s Alternative Expenditure Limitation, commonly known as “home rule.” Arizona voters approved a tax reform package in 1980, subsequently added to the Arizona State Constitution. This reform limited what cities and towns could spend in their annual budget and gave the state the authority to impose a limit to spending. This Alternative Expenditure Limitation requires a vote every four years to allow a town, city or county to set the expenditure limit annually, based on the budget adopted by the town or city council or county board of supervisors. For the counter argument, “Vote ‘NO’ on ‘home rule'” by Sedona resident Mike Schroeder, CLICK HERE. These opinion pieces were not fact-checked and only edited for punctuation and Associated Press and Larson Newspapers style.
Vote ‘YES’ on ‘home rule’
Since moving to Sedona, I have twice voted in favor of “home rule,” formally known as the Alternative Expenditure Limitation. It always made sense to me that our community should make its own budgeting decisions. After being elected to the Sedona City Council in 2024 and participating in the development of two municipal budgets, I am even more convinced that “home rule” remains the right choice for Sedona.
I’ve heard many questions and concerns about “home rule” over the past months. That’s healthy. Residents should ask questions before voting on critical issues. However, many of the concerns come from misunderstandings about “home rule.”
At its core, “home rule” is about local control. It allows Sedona’s elected officials, working through a transparent public process with input from residents, to adopt a budget based on the community’s current needs rather than a state spending formula created more than four decades ago.
Arizona’s expenditure limit dates back to 1980. Under that formula, a city’s spending authority is based largely on what it spent in 1979-80, adjusted for population growth and inflation. Sedona wasn’t incorporated until 1988, so our limit is based primarily on county data rather than anything truly reflective of Sedona’s needs, then or now.
Much has changed since then. The services residents expect, the infrastructure we maintain and municipal responsibilities have all evolved. “Home rule” allows Sedona’s budgeting process to reflect today’s realities instead of yesterday’s assumptions.
It’s also important to understand what “home rule” is and what it is not. “Home rule” is not a tax increase. Sedona does not levy a property tax and whether “home rule” passes or fails has no impact on the city’s tax rates or the amount of revenue collected. “Home rule” simply determines whether the city can use those revenues to provide services and make investments that benefit our community.
Likewise, a “yes” vote is not a vote for bigger government. It is a vote to allow budgeting decisions to be made locally by officials who are accountable to Sedona voters, rather than by an antiquated one-size-fits-all formula.
Without “home rule,” the city’s spending authority would be significantly reduced. Even accounting for allowable exemptions, Sedona would have far less flexibility to fund the services residents rely on. Public safety, streets, wastewater, parks, recreation, transit and infrastructure investments would all face difficult challenges under the state’s outdated expenditure limit.
That doesn’t mean every service would disappear overnight, but it would mean far fewer options, more difficult budget decisions and less ability for the city to respond to changing community needs. “Home rule” gives Sedona the flexibility to plan responsibly while continuing to make those decisions in public, with residents at the table.
City support for most local nonprofits would inevitably end as these are not considered essential government functions. That would mean no more support for Hope House of Sedona, Meals on Wheels, the Sedona Art Center and the Community Library Sedona, just to name a few. It would also mean the end of support for the Sedona International Film Festival, including its attempt to relocate to the Cultural Park.
Some suggest voting against “home rule” as a way to limit city spending. However, there are more effective and less disruptive ways to influence the city’s priorities. The best way is to stay engaged. Attend budget workshops and City Council meetings. Share your ideas during public comment. Email or call your elected officials. Most importantly, vote for councilors who reflect your priorities and your vision for Sedona.
I’ve also heard suggestions that a Permanent Base Adjustment is a better alternative. It is worthwhile exploring as a long-term solution, but it is not an immediate replacement for “home rule.” A PBA would require additional public education, voter approval and implementation time. “Home rule” provides the continuity the city needs today while allowing discussions about future options.
For more than 30 years, Sedona voters have approved “home rule” because they recognize the importance of local decision-making. As a City Council member, I think that decisions about Sedona’s budget should continue to be made here in Sedona, through open meetings, public discussion and officials who answer directly to the people they serve.
A “yes” vote on “home rule” is a vote for local accountability, local decision-making and the flexibility to meet our community’s changing needs. Most importantly, it reflects confidence that the people who know Sedona best are the people who live here. That’s why I’ll be voting “yes” on “home rule” and I hope you’ll join me.
Derek Pfaff
Sedona City Councilman



















