
Just two years short of three decades teaching in West Sedona School, Theresa Zaun will not be returning to her classroom this fall.
Zaun said she is happy with the decades of memories in her classroom.
Zaun originally attended Northern Arizona University, where she was in a rotation to student teach at Big ParkCommunity School in the Village of Oak Creek and then at WSS. She taught first in Beaver Creek Elementary School then applied to a WSS position when it opened up.
“If you need to get something done … she’s your go-to person,” SOCSD Superintendent Tom Swaninger, Ed.D., said at the May 12 meeting. “Anything that you needed, it didn’t matter if you needed something that had to do with curriculum, if you needed something that had to do with a connection in the community, if you needed a T-shirt designed, you go to Theresa’s Zaun and she would make that happen.”
She said her favorite thing about West Sedona was the family atmosphere.
“The teachers I started with, they taught me to look out for each other,” she said. “If somebody was sick, the list would come out and we’d bring them meals.”
The Sedona-Oak Creek School District Governing Board held a recognition event for the retirees on May 12.
Among those leaving the school district are Zaun, Maureen Barton, Judy York, Karen Hughes, Shelly Mullins and Stacy Smith.
Resignations the board approved since the beginning of the calendar year included Sedona Red Rock Jr./Sr. High School Principal Heather Isom, who is leaving to be principal at Cactus Shadows High School in Cave Creek, track coach Sean Eicher, Athletics Director Peter Brock, Curriculum Director Chelle Kemper and theater teacher Cae Collmar.
Retiring
While Zaun said the decision to retire was technically hers, it wasn’t because she wanted to. She wanted to stay to hit 30 years, but she said she felt forced to leave early.
Public teachers are required to be evaluated every year.
In these evaluations, there are four levels a teacher can score across 22 categories: Highly Effective, Effective, Developing and Ineffective.
Between 2013 and 2024, she never received anything below “Effective.” In her last evaluation in December, she received 15 “Developing” and “Ineffective” marks.
Zaun said she performed poorly largely because she wasn’t feeling well.
“I had the first one [of the school year] in November,” she said. “So, I asked her, I knew it went horrible. I said ‘I’m sorry, I have a raging headache,’ which was weird because I never get a headache.”
After WSS Principal Alisa Steig rescheduled the evaluation, it came while she was sick with what she later found out was viral pharyngitis.
Zaun requested a review and reconsideration for the evaluation results on May 25, after her retirement was finalized, because she said she didn’t feel like it was an adequate account of her teaching. It was denied a few days later.
While Swaninger said his hands were tied discussing personnel matters, he said it was Zaun’s decision to retire.
“We remain grateful for the many contributions she has made throughout her long and impactful career,” he recently wrote. “I wish her nothing but the best and sincerely thank her for her years of service to students, families and education.”
Recognition
Swaninger said he’d requested some of those retiring to submit someinformation on their history with the district, considering he’s been with SOCSD three years. He read about Zaun and Barton, a WSS secondgrade teacher.
Barton is leaving after 32 years with the district; she was on leave for the 2025-26 school year. She began in 1994 in payroll for the district office. She also served as the secretary to the district’s first superintendent, Nancy Alexander.
“She transitioned into the classroom in 2002, where she taught business and journalism at the Sedona Red Rock High School,” Swaninger said. “I don’t think that I even knew that until I read that. I always saw you as an elementary teacher.”
As the journalism teacher, she managed the yearbook, The Sting student newspaper and other school programs.
“Helped students gain hands-on journalism and broadcasting experience through collaborating with Sedona Red Rock News and KAZM radio,” Swaninger said. “How cool of our students to be able to have that experience as students.”
The Scorpion Shout Out column, which Barton helped produce every Wednesday in the NEWS, was discontinued in 2018 when the journalism class was cut.
The two teachers had sent Swaninger a list of accomplishments, which he said he asked all the retirees to do.
Zaun “is an inspiration,” local philanthropist Basil Maher said during the meeting. “Mimi and I have two employees actually, two different jobs, and they both were students of Theresa’s. One of them actually even had her two children in Theresa’s class.”
He said he got involved with the Parent-Teacher Association when his children were in Zaun’s class.
Zaun played a large role in the PTA every year except her very first as a WSS teacher.
Every year, she raised funds for its annual carnival and helped run the book fair. She had an annual goal of raising $20,000 for the event.
She was also a part-time student herself, recently earning a master’s in education administration from Grand Canyon University.
School Counselor
WSS Counselor Karen Hughes will also not be returning after the board approved a reduction in force including her position.
Instead of a counselor at WSS next year, there will be a “wellness coordinator.”
Hughes, who’s been at WSS for about eight years, said when the job description came out for the wellness coordinator position, it was nearly identical to what she did, but included discipline.
“The district created a new role designed to support not only the social-emotional needs of students, but also student discipline and behavioral matters as a primary responsibility,” Swaninger wrote.
Hughes said she often stood in on discipline matters when Steig was unavailable and even when there were principals around, including Steig’s predecessors; teachers often called her to do discipline work because she had a relationship with those students already.
“In an elementary level, for a school counselor, it kind of falls to that role,” Hughes said.
She said she had originally discussed the idea of retiring, or retiring to return through Education Services Inc. with Steig in October 2024.
When she decided she couldn’t retire yet, for her own financial reasons and because she wanted more time with the students she kept relationships with, she was told her position was being reduced to part time for the 2025-26 school year.
The reduction in force for the rest of her time as a counselor was approved March 10.
Steig did not reply to an email for more information.
“We have applied for a grant that would provide a full-time social worker at West Sedona School,” Swaninger wrote. “We are optimistic about receiving that position and look forward to hearing the results of the application process in the near future.”