45.4 F
Sedona
Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Free speech case in Surprise moves to federal court4 min read

While we are a hyper-local newspaper, there are often news items in Arizona or the nation that pique our interest with regard to democracy, the rule of law, journalism or the Constitution and warrant a public discussion in our newspapers.

We have twice covered an incident on Aug. 20, 2024 when Skip Hall, the mayor of the city of Surprise, a suburb in the northwest Phoenix Valley, had 32-year-old Surprise resident Rebekah Massie arrested during a Surprise City Council meeting’s call to the public.

Massie was at the meeting to criticize a 4.4% pay raise for Surprise City Attorney Robert Wingo, alleging he had violated state law and the Arizona State Bar’s standards by failing to respond to election issues raised about the town clerk during the recent primary election. Massie spoke during the call to the public, which Verde Valley residents know is the portion of municipal and county meetings during which residents can speak on any topic they deem of public interest that is not on that meeting’s agenda.

Residents speak at nearly every meeting in the Verde Valley, from county boards, city and town councils and local commissions, in hopes that their concerns may make it onto a future agenda, or just to voice their opinions to their elected and appointed leaders.

The only exception to this important and vital pillar of representative government is, of course, the Yavapai Community College Governing Board, under the dictatorial authority of wannabe totalitarian Board Chairwoman Deb McCasland — who fears any public criticism from you, the voters and taxpayers who fund her college. McCasland has refused to agendize a call to the public since late 2024 perhaps knowing robust criticism of her mismanagement of the college would be deafening.

In Surprise, Hall repeatedly interrupted Massie while she was speaking, claiming she was violating a new council policy that banned complaints about or criticisms of city employees, which we wrote in an August 2024 editorial “is an open and naked violation of citizens’ First Amendment freedom of speech and First Amendment right to criticize public officials: ‘Congress shall make no law … abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press; or the right of the people peaceably to assemble, and to petition the government for a redress of grievances.’”

Advertisement

Following Massie’s arrest, the Philadelphia-based free speech and civil rights organization Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression tweeted: “City of Surprise: We’ll see you in court” and took up Massie’s case to defend her right — and all of ours — to criticize the government without fear of censorship, harassment or arrest.

FIRE’s Media Relations Specialist Jack Whitten has been in contact with our newspaper since, giving us updates. In a court ruling issued Oct. 23, 2024, Maricopa County Justice of the Peace Gerald A. Williams slammed the city of Surprise and the prosecution for infringing on Massie’s rights and threw out the case calling the city’s actions “objectively outrageous,” a violation of free speech and without probable cause. Williams wrote that “no branch of any federal, state or local government in this country should ever attempt to control the content of political speech.” hE further wrote that Massie “should not have faced criminal prosecution once for expressing her political views.”

Under public pressure, Surprise repealed its unconstitutional policy on Sept. 18, 2024. Incoming Surprise Mayor-elect Kevin Sartor condemned Hall’s actions before Hall left office that November, stating to the Arizona Daily Independent, “What happened to Rebekah Massie is unacceptable. No citizen should ever be arrested for voicing their concerns, especially in a forum specifically designed for public input.”

Massie has since filed a lawsuit in federal court, which United States District Judge Roslyn O. Silver allowed to move forward in a ruling issued Jan. 6, 2026. Massie’s First and Fourth Amendment claims, which were not challenged by the motion, and a claim under Arizona’s Open Meeting Law will proceed to discovery, according to Whitten.

“The Open Meeting Law expressly limits how government bodies may impose regulations on public comments,” Whitten wrote. “This is key for defending the rights of all Arizonans to speak out and criticize their government.”

“We’re going to continue to fight not only to vindicate Rebekah’s constitutional rights, but to ensure that all Arizonans are free to speak their minds,” FIRE attorney Adam Steinbaugh told us. “All of us have the right to criticize our government without being arrested.”

We applaud FIRE for advocating for the rights of all Arizonans and Americans. When a single government threatens the rights of a single citizen, they threaten us all of us.

Christopher Fox Graham

Christopher Fox Graham is the managing editor of the Sedona Rock Rock News, The Camp Verde Journal and the Cottonwood Journal Extra. Hired by Larson Newspapers as a copy editor in 2004, he became assistant manager editor in October 2009 and managing editor in August 2013. Graham has won awards for editorials, investigative news reporting, headline writing, page design and community service from the Arizona Newspapers Association. Graham has also been a guest contributor in Editor & Publisher magazine and featured in the LA Times, New York Post and San Francisco Chronicle. He lectures on journalism, media law and the First Amendment and is a nationally recognized performance aka slam poet. In January 2025, the International Astronomical Union formally named asteroid 29722 Chrisgraham (1999 AQ23) in his honor at the behest of Lowell Observatory, citing him as "an American journalist and longtime managing editor of Sedona Red Rock News. He is a nationally-recognized slam poet who has written and performed multiple poems about Pluto and other space themes."

- Advertisement -